Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Jan 8, 2010 03:40 PM

Who has the best french onion soup in nyc ?

Looking to find out what restaurant has the best french onion soup in nyc

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. if you like cheese, try Artisanal. Not sure if the soup is the best in town but it certainly is good!

    1. Don't know how "French" it is, but I love the crock of Onion and Porter (and lots of cheese) soup at the Waterfront Ale House (Brooklyn & Manhattan). Wish I had some today.

      1 Reply
      1. re: efdee

        Agreed. The soup is surprisingly amazing.

      2. Thanks...wen to Artisanal, but they were under renovation and had no onion soup on the menu ! So went to always delicious. Will have to try the soup at Artisanal and the Waterfront Ale house. Thanks.

        4 Replies
        1. re: triattylp09

          are they really renovating? are they still open??

          1. re: ossauiraty

            Still menu...and I believe goes back to full service/full menu tomorrow I would call and double check if ur planning on going in the next few days

            1. re: ossauiraty

              Yes they are still open...running a limited menu. I believe they are supposed to be back to full service/full menu tomorrow. If you are planning on going within the next few days, I would call and make sure.

            2. i thought the onion soup at waterfront ale house in manhattan was awful. i went just for the soup on a cold snowy day, i was so upset. it tasted like i was drinking pure beef broth. sorry i have to disagree.

              4 Replies
              1. re: mch

                Completely agree with WAH. The place has fallen off dramatically the food is awful. The best FOS I ever had was at Les Halles.

                1. re: mch

                  I've never had the FOS at either WAH location, but the common wisdom (and my own informed opinion) is that the food at the brooklyn location is significantly better than the manhattan one.

                  1. re: mch

                    Gotta say I'm surprised as I've always found it deep and rich.