Hi there, two of my favorite places to eat in the keys are Lorelei and the Fish House.
Lorelei has a good selection of food and drinks in a fun outdoor bar on the water. The winner is the key lime pie which is served frozen - we stop to get this pie on every trip to Key West.
The Fish House has delicious fresh fish dishes and key lime pie. I highly recommend the Matecumbe!
Lorelei Cabana Bar
81924 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Fish House Restaurant & Seafood Market
Mm 102 4, Key Largo, FL 33037