Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Dec 29, 2009 04:24 PM

Italian meatballs and sausage. Cooking preference?

When you're making meatballs and/or Italian sausage with marinara sauce, do you prefer to add raw and cook in the sauce? Or, do you prefer to brown and cook before adding to sauce?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I cook the meatballs raw in the sauce. I have occasionally browned prior to adding, but my MIL always simmered them in sauce so husband prefers them that way! I can't eat red sauce, so I am all for easier/less cleanup when I do make them for him & the kids.

    1. Meatballs are cooked first in the oven on a cookie sheet to brown. Sausage is added in raw to the sauce.

      1. jfood bakes his meatballs in the oven on the rack he cools cookies so the fat drains off.

        jfood griddles the sausage to a nice brown before adding to the sauce.

        1. After observing decades of grandmother, mother and aunts cooking meatballls in various ways, I have taken to cooking them raw in sauce as my preferred method. Browning does seem to help sausages, however, so I do brown those.

          I came upon this many years ago after observing my grandmother, whose meatballs and sauce were the best, of course, when she was in a hurry and did not brown the meatballs she was preparing as she usually did. It was the first time I had ever seen her do it, and they were delicious and juicy when they were done. I concluded that you can skip this step and avoid inadvertently adding cooking oil (as a result of browning) to the sauce.

          I think for this to work, a couple of things are required. For one thing, I use a mix of beef/pork/veal, but the meat is somewhat lean. I have heard that the rendered fat from beef in the 75-25 range ends up floating on top of the tomato sauce. I would just skim it, but some people object to this. I also think you need to have very hot sauce ready in the sauce pot, and that you must carefully place the meatballs in, in layers if you have to. You must be patient enough to hold off stirring until the hot tomato sauce sears the outside of the meatballs to some degree of firmness, so patience is very, very important or they will break up.

          I have heard of people baking their meatballs before dropping in sauce too.

          My secret is to add some tomato sauce to the meatball mix (before it gets hot in the pot) so that there is some tomato flavor inside the meatball as well. Not quite a delicious as what I remember from Grandma's kitchen, but darned close.

          1. I love the texture of the meatballs cooked in the sauce, and the flavor of the sauce is improved tenfold by the cooking of the meat in the sauce.