Is this a Florida thread? Miami area peut-être? Va. or D.C. ? and who the hell knows where "third-Caffe dell'Amore" is located? Please be Florida regional specific in your posts.
Hope you chose one or the other restaurants and had a good New Year's Eve wherever you are. Report back on which restaurant you chose.
i would give Sea Salt a try--even though i had a bad "experience" there (the food was great but the service was terrible as they forgot to put in our entree order and we sat there for over an hr after the appetizer was served. they probably want to do a good job. enough time to get the kinks out.
best New Year's dinner i ever had: The Inn at Little Washington--it was flawless.