HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

Soccarat Paella - AWFUL

It takes a lot for me to black list a restaurant, and publicly warn people against it, but considering the love affair people have been having with this place I really felt compelled to share my experience over the past 48 hours.

It all began on Sunday night, at 5:30 p.m., a half hour aftert they opened. It was a rainy, miserable night and the city was pretty dead. I showed up with my husband and a friend from out of town. FYI, they don't take reservations and you can't even speak to a live person when you call, you can only leave a message. Anyway, the restaurant has two sides, one room filled with tables the other with one four-top and a long bar with seating. We were informed it would be an hour wait to sit at the bar; they refused to seat us at the four-top table (we were too few) and the other room was completely empty. Idiocy. We left and said we'd try again another night.

Fast forward to yesterday night. Hubbie and I were in the neighborhood and, only because people rave about this place and we have been craving arroz negro since we went to the best place for it in Madrid with our friends who live there, we decide to give it another shot. We're told the wait will be 20 minutes, and they take our cell number and offer to call us if we want to have a cocktail nearby. We get the call 50 minutes later; after saying we were just around the corner, they guy tells us to hurry right over. We leave half-drunk drinks at the bar and hurry over, only to be told we have to wait -- and we do, another 15 minutes. In the interim, we put in our order for the arroz negro. When we are finally seated, we order the gambas al ajillo which arrive almost instantaneously and were completely unseasoned except for the garlic and oil they were sitting in and the shrimp were overcooked. We were starving and ate them. Finally, the arroz negro arrives and it looks, well, disgusting. The rice is in a thin layer; sprinkled on top of the rice are the a few boiled shrimp, a total of two scallops which were sliced into about 6 paper thin slices and scattered, a few pieces of raw red pepper and a few fava beans (not in season) also sliced in half, all boiled and totally unseasoned. The aioli they served with it had the consistency of dried out mayonaisse, not creamy at all, just lumpy. We dig in, considering our hunger and how long we've waited. The first spoonfuls reveal there are absolutely no calamari in this dish. After we try it, the rice is hard and crunchy. We dig around in the pan to see that none of the bottom is crispy, and we realize that the rice is just raw. Disappointed, we send it back. The bartender/waiter comes back from the kitchen and I assume he'll over us a free tapas while we wait for another paella. NOT SO. Instead, he informs us that the chef has asked if we would like some tapas INSTEAD. When pressed, he explains that they both tasted it and it was fine. We ask him to bring it back out, and we cut into rice grains and show him how they are not cooked through. After bringing it back to the kitchen, he returns and informs us that they chef said it was cooked perfectly and we can have tapas if we want. So, basically, the chef said f**k them, I know what I'm doing and I'm not going to try to please them with another paella. How European.

Needless to say, we walked out and spent the rest of the way home trying to pick uncooked rice out of our teeth.

Do yourselves a favor, if you're looking for good paella (or anything else, from what I could see) don't come here. Malaga on the UES is much better, probably El Faro as well though their food can be underseasoned, and at least their service is pleasant.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. I have to say, I agree - this place is terrible. I took a friend of mine there (he really loves paella) and we were disappointed with the food (bland shrimp, undercooked paella.) The thing that really put me over the top was at the end of our meal. The host clearly wants us to leave so he can seat one of the (many) people waiting. He offers us a glass of sangria if we will move from the table to one of the chairs in the entryway. We reluctantly do this, but then we are basically blocking the door and the servers can't get by. So he pushes us out into their "patio," which involves going through the kitchen into an alley. We were completely dumfounded. Literally, there we are - holding glasses of sangria, by ourselves, standing on a concrete slab behind the kitchen. No tables or chairs, no lights. Just us with our "complimentary" wine. Unbelievable. We left 30 seconds later, to no thanks from the host. Will never go back.

    1 Reply
    1. re: chorosch

      Wow, chorosch, I can't believe your story is worse than mine. As to prdct's comment below, and not to be combative, but I don't see how opening up more space would make the service worse or the chef that much more of an a***ole. I think they are just very, very comfortable serving what many consider good food (because, notably, in my opinion, really fantastic Spanish fare doesn't exist in NYC, much like really killer Mexican food). I'll leave this place to the masses, just sorry I killed a whole night on it. My pizza from my corner shop Delizia on First Ave was, on the other hand, as delicious as it always is.

    2. Sounds like an awful experience--I'm sorry you had such bad food and service. I will say though that my two experiences here have been great. Both times I had long waits but the staff dealt with it well--taking my cellphone and calling promptly when our seats were ready. I've also had delicious paella--perfectly cooked with plenty of the crunchy layer. I will note that the last time I was there a few weeks ago they had not yet opened the second room which I presume is the new wine bar. Maybe that is causing some new issues?

      1. I've had two opposite experiences. When Soccorat first opened, it was lovely, despite the wait. Granted, it was a warm spring day and we arrived right at opening around 5pm. Both paellas (the meat and seafood) were perfectly crisp, the service was brisk and typically Spanish, and the dessert was out of this world (some sort of Catalonian fried chocolate). The tapas weren't the best I've had, but the gazpacho was the best in the city I had all summer, hands down.

        The second time though, it was much more like nattie's. It was a rainy weekend evening where we waited about an hour. We were told we were next to be seated, but then another 1/2 hour rolled by. The paella (house special this time) was greasy and the rice was soggy. The "service" was non-existent. I'm used to what Americans perceive as rudeness by Spanish servers, but this wasn't it -- this was just flat out inattentive. The only high point was the gazpacho was still good.

        So the question I pose to you, fellow hounds, is did the place go downhill irrevocably or has anyone had a good experience lately? I'd love to go back as when the paella is done right, it's wonderful.

        1 Reply
        1. re: lawstud

          Im going tonight! Will report back in the AM. I have only been once - in August and it was divine. My friend went about 6 weeks ago and also raved. We shall see what we are in for tonight.

        2. I go pretty often and love it there but then I'm a night owl and rarely get there before 10:30 PM. I wonder are they having issues with crowds at prime times? I can't imagine that this will get any better given that their wine bar next door just opened. I have to note that I have never had a bad paella there. They have always been perfectly crisp and the last few bites are to die for.

          1. I just went last night (12/17). Party of 2 and we arrived right after work before 5:30pm. Were the only patrons in the place until about 6pm. Space was filled by 7pm (im talking about the original space with the single long table - not the wine bar next door).

            Meal and service was as good as in the past. Had 1 app, glass of wine and the arroz negro. Food was hot and cooked wonderfully - servers were friendly and relaxed.

            Obviously I can't speak to what happens as the night progresses. Then again, Im not one of those people willing to wait for a table either. If I can't make a reservation somewhere, I don't go (unless I can arrive at 5:30 and know that I have no line)! I just don't have the patience no matter how great the food is.

            Hopefully the poor performance was just a temporary fluke!!

            1. i didn't have a great experience when i went there either. the food was mediocre. the service was actually pretty decent though. the only real problem i had was their a/c. we were sitting next to the bar and the a/c was blowing in my face and my food the entire night, which made the food cold minutes after it arrived. we asked if they could turn it down but they weren't able to because it would've gotten too stuffy in the small space. i'm not sure why the air has to be so strong and why the vent is pointed downwards directly onto the table. i'm not sure if the food being ice cold did anything to affect the flavor, but it seemed bland. i wouldn't go back.

                1. I had a similar experience to many of the previous posters. We arrived at the restaurant on a recent Sat nite at around 5:30 and were told there was a 45 minute wait. So we headed over to the wine bar next door and split a pitcher of red sangria (very good) and chorizo (OK), both expensive though. We were told to order right away and that our food would be ready just as we sat down. So far so good. As promised we were seated about 30-45 minutes later in the last two spots in the back at the communal table adjacent to my friend ( I preferred this) as opposed to across from each other. Had the Paella Negro, which I thought was very good, although I would have preferred it a little more done so that the rice sticks to the pan and is crispier. The seafood was top notch and plentiful and the garlic aioli was wonderful.

                  Now for the not so great. We really had the sense they were rushing us as they continually emptied the remaining sangria in our pitcher into our still half full wine glasses. It became more evident as they attempted to fill up our plates with the remaining paella from the pan. When I suggested that they leave it there and we would help ourselves to the remaining food, the waiter said that they “needed the pan” (and I am sure the seats as well!). I found this a turn off and believe that being rushed at a somewhat upscale restaurant where we waited a while for a table to be a real no-no. What was most surprising is that the owner of this restaurant also runs La Nacional on 14th st, a restaurant as laid back and unpretentious as Socarrat was high energy and trendy.

                  In summary, great paella, but the rushed service was a turn off.

                  -----
                  La Nacional
                  239 W 14th St, New York, NY 10011

                  Socarrat
                  259 W 19th St, New York, NY 10011

                  1. The tapas are pretty good, at best.

                    I even gave the NoLIta location a shot because of the continued raves only to be disappointed with the paella.

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: RRNYC

                      LOL these old posts , I know Chowhounders like people to search and add to the old threads, but even though it's nice to see the same people from years ago still here, and see how things have changed. There should be a limit on how far back we go, and when it is time to start a new post. Anyway, i found the paella decent at Socarrat but the place is way overrated. I also thought the paella at Tertulla way overrated. The paella at El Faro, I used to think was good and it was horrible about a month ago. I had great paella in Spain, I wonder if there is really any excellent paella in NYC.

                      1. re: foodwhisperer

                        Sorry, I didn't look at how old this thread was