HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Family Style Italian

ssp242 Dec 6, 2009 09:22 PM

Just saw Throwdown with Bobby Flay and the episode was about Rao's. It got me craving a family style Italian restaurant now. Seeing all the posts on how impossible it is to get into Rao's, what are the good family style Italian restos in the city or out? I've been to Carmine's and Tony Di Napoli's, I know they're touristy but I liked them. What else is out there?

Thanks in advance!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. m
    ml77 RE: ssp242 Dec 6, 2009 09:39 PM

    I like Tony's too. It's unfair to compare it to Babbo or Scarpetta -- it's not trying to be that. But it's good at what it does, which is family style Italian (really , Italian-American, what many call "red sauce").

    I also like Serafina. It's not family style, but some of its menu is closer to authentic Italian than Tony's. And it does offer many italian comfort food items like pizza.

    3 Replies
    1. re: ml77
      thew RE: ml77 Dec 7, 2009 04:59 AM

      the tony's on the UES seems a bit better than the times square one

      1. re: ml77
        ssp242 RE: ml77 Dec 7, 2009 05:18 PM

        I've been to Babbo and plan to go to Scarpetta soon as well. I never was going to compare Tony's to those type of restaurants. I mean, they're both Italian but it's still like comparing apples to oranges.

        I may try Sambuca I guess. Any suggestions off island?

        1. re: ml77
          Steve R RE: ml77 Dec 8, 2009 05:58 AM

          Without comparing apples and oranges, I'd still say that Tony D & Carmines dont do more than a mediocre job with this "red sauce" family style eyetalian. Since the OP also posted on the Outer Boroughs board, I recommended Queen (Bklyn) and Park Side (Queens). Someone else recommended Dominick's (Bronx -- Arthur Ave). All are much better. In Manhattan, Piccolo Angelo on Hudson is not strictly "family style" but is large sharable portions of much better red sauce food than Tony D or Carmine. MUCH better. And a great owner too (Renato).

        2. r
          rkaene RE: ssp242 Dec 7, 2009 04:33 AM

          Has anyone tried Sambuca on W 72? Family style Italian- I have been thinking about going with a large group.

          2 Replies
          1. re: rkaene
            smokeandapancake RE: rkaene Dec 8, 2009 09:08 AM


            1. re: rkaene
              uwser RE: rkaene Dec 8, 2009 02:53 PM

              I haven't been in a while (maybe 3 years?) but the few times I've been to Sambuca I thought it was perfectly fine . Definitely better than Carmine's, and probably better than Tony's. Dean's is a good recommendation too, although it's always struck me as a bit more of a place to go with a bunch of kids.

            Show Hidden Posts