Log In / Sign Up
HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >
n
NJBloke Nov 24, 2009 06:49 AM

3ft. hoagies for party in lower Bergen County - any recommendations?

I am planning a holiday party for approximately 30 people. I need recommendations for delis/specialty stores/super markets, etc. that make large hoagies. Quality meats/cheeses/bread/ assorted salads, etc. I am supplying two three feet hoagies (American/Italian), salads and beer/wine; guests are bringing hors d'oeuvres /desserts, etc.

As a side, had anyone had the hoagies from Stop and Shop, either their own brand or the Boars Head? Many thanks!

  1. f
    foodismylife Dec 15, 2009 10:39 AM

    italian riveria in waldwick is also a nice italian provisions store
    nice people and very good food
    i enjoy their stuff but never had a three foot sub
    for trulyb remarkable go to faicco's on bleecker st in the city
    home made stuff
    beyond belief
    sinatr'a used to get his meats there
    great butcher as well

    1 Reply
    1. re: foodismylife
      b
      buckytom Dec 21, 2009 08:58 PM

      The best Italian sandwich shop in Bergen County is Mucci's in Saddle Brook. I don't think they do giant sized sanwiches, but I'm sure they cater sandwich platters that can be sliced to feed a large crowd.
      Vitamia is also very good, as doxy mentioned. A close second. If you go there, see if they have bresaola and fresh bufala mozzarella. It's one of the few places I've found that carry bresaola, and their bufala mozz is truely fresh. Anything more than a few days old and bufala (as all fresh mozz's) loses so much of it's flavour.

    2. d
      doxy216 Nov 24, 2009 07:04 AM

      You didn't say exactly where you are, but lower Bergen does have the best Italian delis. In Fairview there is DePalmas on Bergen Boulevard, excellent selection, also on Bergen Boulevard, more North, I believe Ridgefield, is Tutto Gastronomica, next to tutto modo Mio, I hope I'm even close. They are wonderful. In Englewood there is Bartolomeos on Dean St. big selection and quality stuff. I stay away from Jerrys in Englewood. Of course there is the best, Vitamia in Garfield/Lodi , was there Sunday pure perfection and Viscentini Brothers in Lodi . This is a subject dear to me because I was raised on all this good stuff and have since moved to Northern Bergen, the gastro wasteland. I still make my pilgramage down for the real stuff. Good luck.

      2 Replies
      1. re: doxy216
        n
        NJBloke Nov 24, 2009 07:10 AM

        Thanks doxy216. I am located in Rutherford.

        1. re: NJBloke
          c
          cosmic_charlie Dec 12, 2009 10:16 AM

          The Roasted Pepper in East Rutherford makes DELICIOUS subs and food! 366 Paterson Ave.
          I absolutely love their prosciutto, sopressata, cappocola, hot peppers, roasted red peppers, resh mozzarella with oil and vinegar. get it all on a semolina roll. order a day or so ahead for the large subs.....$13/ft. dont go to stop and shop. these people are fantastic and make great food. They are the best.

      Share with your friendsX