Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Nov 12, 2009 08:57 AM

How do I avoid mushy potatoes in my stew?

Recently I made a traditional Irish stew. Meat, potatoes and veg.

I cooked the meat a bit, and the potatoes, separately. Then dumped them in the beef broth with some veg. I cooked for several hours and by the end, my stew was very mushy, all the potatoes had mushed into the broth. Is this suppose to happen? It still tasted very good but I dont think I wanted it to be a big mushed stew?

Let me know if anyone can help or has any insight?

Thanks so much!!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Did you boil the potatoes separately? If they were nearly fully cooked then it was just too much time cooking in the stew--was this in a slow cooker?

    When I make beef stew I cook the meat for about 1 1/2 hrs then add the raw veggies and potatoes (carrots cut into large thick coins and potatoes in appx 2" chunks) and cook for another hour or so. This is in the oven at 275-300 F and not in a slow cooker.

    1 Reply
    1. re: iluvcookies

      to KTinNYC's point, I use either Yukon Gold or new potatoes in beef stew.

    2. Avoid mushy potatoes by not over cooking....Add them towards the end of cooking....30 minutes or so should do the trick......


      1. You can partially boil them to wash away a little starch and then add them in about the last half hour or so of simmering.

        1. The other posters are corect in saying you are overcooking your potatoes but the type of potato you use is important as well if you want the potatoes to stay intact. Waxy potatoes hold there shape better then starchy ones.

          1. First off, I suspect you used Idaho (baking) potatoes. They will break up easily if overcooked just the slightest, but it's also why they're usually the potato of choice for mashing. For a traditional stew there is no reason to cook the potatoes alone. You just figure how much cooking time the potatoes require (always less than the beef, or almost always) and then add them to the pot that much time before the beef is done. Any "waxy" potatoes will hold their shape well in a stew. I like red potatoes, but the standard waxy potatoes work too. It's pretty difficulty to cook them to the fall-apart stage, and I often use mine unpeeled, especially when using small "new" potatoes. Good luck!