HOME > Chowhound > Florida >

Thanksgiving Pies in Tampa

m
Miss E Nov 10, 2009 01:18 PM

For those of us who are not baking up a storm this year (or any year), where are the best pumpkin, apple, pecan and cherry pies to be found in Tampa? (I guess other desserts are possible, but pies are a must.)

We always used to get ours at the Mike's Pies shop in the same plaza with Pane Rustica, but that closed over a year ago; then we ordered Mike's pies from The Junction, but it closed, too! I see that you can pre-order Mike's pies from Fresh Market, but frankly, last year they were frozen when we picked them up (at the MP shop, they used to be warm, mmmm), so I want a new source this year.

I'm thinking Pane Rustica, but other ideas are welcome...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. askdrtodd RE: Miss E Nov 10, 2009 03:47 PM

    Grannybubba makes an insane pie, they refund your money if it isn't the best pie you've ever eaten. We had one last halloween and it lasted about 3 minutes at the in-laws house. www.grannybubba.com. they ship all over the place but they're located about 20 minutes north of here and you can pick up.

    1. c
      cheddarcheese32 RE: Miss E Nov 10, 2009 05:07 PM

      JJ Gandy's Pies is in Palm Harbor, which isn't so convenient but their pies are wonderful! Their Pumpkin Chiffon pie is great for Thanksgiving. www.jjgandys.com/

      And last year's holiday pie offerings @ Pane Rustica sounded fantastic.

      Show Hidden Posts