HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

CI Apple Upside-Down Cake

valerie Nov 6, 2009 04:45 AM

Has anyone made the Cook's Illustrated Apple Upside-Down Cake from their September issue? I am in charge of desserts for Thanksgiving and I am contemplating making it. However, I am much more of a cook than a baker and since I don't want to start experimenting when I have to bring dessert to my sister's house, I'm wondering if it is really good, or should I just stick with what I know and make an apple-cranberry pie...

Any thoughts on it? Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Wheetie RE: valerie Nov 8, 2009 10:30 AM

    My friend just gave me the recipe. I haven't tried it, but she (who is a fantastic cook) said it was excellent. Why don't you try it out before hand just to make sure.

    1 Reply
    1. re: Wheetie
      valerie RE: Wheetie Nov 9, 2009 05:58 AM

      Yes, I could do that. But I work full time, have 2 young kids and am trying to lose weight so I was trying to avoid that for a variety of reasons!

    2. pitu RE: valerie Nov 9, 2009 09:17 AM

      Since you're trying not to make a bunch of cakes in the coming weeks, I'll share my experiences...none of which are CI. I made an apple upside down cake last week, the recipe from Lebovitz's Room For Dessert...plum huckleberry upside down cake, but I used hard tart apples. It was deeeelicious, but not as good as the cranberry upside-down cake published in an Alice Waters article in the NYTimes a couple of years ago.
      You could sub an apple for some of those cranberries if you are inclined. It's a great cake, and the top is gooey-jammy.

      Another fruit and cake bit of perfection in the Sir Gawain butter cake that's been passed around this board for a few years. It's super easy - I too am a cook, not a baker. I've made it with a variety of fruits.

      1 Reply
      1. re: pitu
        valerie RE: pitu Nov 9, 2009 10:07 AM

        That cranberry-upside down cake sounds great, thanks! I am not good at improvising when it comes to baking, so not sure if I would add apples, but maybe...I still have some time to decide what to do.

      2. n
        nosnikreplliw RE: valerie Dec 23, 2009 08:29 AM

        it's an easy recipe that makes a very good cake. i used granny smith apples. when they say make sure you don't overcook the apples, they mean it. undercook them.

        would you mind listing the cake ingredients? i wanted to make this for christmas, but i'm away from home (and my magazine).

        Show Hidden Posts