We've moved some posts about cooking with pomegranate molasses to the Home Cooking board, where the whole community can more easily chime in. Feel free to post your tips there:
or if you are downtown, al mizan -that little depanneur looking store across the street from the st. mathieu exit of the guy-concordia metro station (st mathieu @ de maisonneuve) definitely has it.
Not in the plateau, but you can definitely get it at Akhavan, in NDG (Sherbrooke, corner Grand Blvd). It comes in a tall glass bottle. I bought it there recently.
You can get it at Atwater market, I forget the name of the store, but it's the one with all the hot sauces, the funky pasta, on the street level. I buy the CLIC brand. However, I bot the last 2 bottles on the weekend, wait a couple weeks.
Let me know if you find some! I've been looking for it for months. Nothing in the European-style grocery stores in my neighborhood, nothing at Aubut... Doesn't Petit Alep have something like that in their menu, though?