Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >
Oct 31, 2009 11:20 AM

The 'Oh My God' Food Awards

As I sat eating an unusually disappointing cheesesteak at BB's last night, my wife and I were talking about what was missing. It was good, it just wasnt 'Oh my god this is unbelievable' good. Hopefully this was a one time event at BB's but who knows- places don't always stay the same over the years.

Along these lines- what food items in restaurants or delis in the Outer Boroughs have you eaten over and over that still make you say or think 'Oh my god this is good' every time you eat them? They don't have to be fancy, they just have to make you have that reaction.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Bahn Mi at Hanco's (the original or the spicy chicken)
    Braised pork dish and the Pastifret at Sue Perette
    Ginger ice cream at Blue Marble
    Sweetbread hash at Po
    Skate at Saul
    La Quercia Acorn edition headcheese at Stinky (comes in a little sealed jar, like $20 ea)
    Wonton soup (but nothing else sadly) at Me and My Egg Roll

    85 Bergen St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

    1 Reply
    1. re: Nehna

      I'd like to add the Ukranian Borscht I had on monday at Teresa's -- husband and I were both pretty blown away by how good it was.

    2. Ages ago, but Pasta con Sarde at Ferdinando's.

      1. DiFara's, obviously.
        Maybe not "oh my God" but at least "This is soooo good--that's why I keep ordering it" in my neighbourhood:
        -sauteed calamari at Beast
        -lambajin pitza at Olive Vine (with lotsa house hot sauce)
        -Franny's pizza
        -pork mofongo at El Castillo de Jagua
        -fried dough brunch at Miriam

        2 Replies
        1. re: chowbie

          Forgot the sticky toffee cake at Beast. That does make me say "OMG."

          1. re: chowbie

            i'll have to second the calamar and sticky toffee at Beast. i get the former at least once a week and smile ear-to-ear upon first forkful each time.

            - skate at james. beautiful flavorful dish
            - grilled lobster w miso butter at blue ribbon sushi, but this is ridiculously expensive for the size of the lob
            - brunch eggs norwegian (i think that's what it's called): poached eggs, smoked salmon, toasted english muffin, hollandaise, greens, at jolie
            - believe it or not, the half plain, half olive and onion pie i had delivered (extra well-done) from antonio's on flatbush last week. it was perfectly balanced crispy tangy greasy old-school bk pizza.
            - shrimp sammy at el castillo on flatbush/park pl, with a side of guac salad and fries
            - mussels the classic herb white wine butter way at le gamin.
            - choc chip bread pudding at blue ribbon. a meal in itself; easily split three ways for dessert.

        2. Most of the food at Tanoreen (esp cauliflower, brussels sprouts, chicken fette)

          Lasagne at Fragole

          Ham & cheese croissant at Mazzola.

          Quesadillas at the Red Hook ballfields.

          7523 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209

          394 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

          1. What a great idea for a post. Here are a few that come to mind (limited to a very tiny geographical radius):

            Lard bread @ Mazzola
            Cavatelli w/ sausage and sage butter @ Frankie's
            Pancakes @ Luluc
            Plain pie w/ basil @ Lucali
            Fried artichokes @ Grocery
            Turkish salad @ Zaytoons
            Mac and cheese with proscuitto @ Paninoteca 275 (RIP)

            575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

            283 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

            1 Reply