Best Bone in Ribeye or filet

[kjrumley]

This is my 1st post so I hope I'm doing this right! I have read several reviews of restaurants here but couldn't find exactly what I wanted. My husband and I are headed into the city this weekend and want a GREAT steak. Love bone in cuts... We are staying in Mid-town but would travel a bit if needed. Would like to keep the total bill < $200. Also like great martinis and wine and a nice ambiance wouldn't hurt! Thanks for your help!

[Imac]

Bring an appetite and go to Morton's on 5th Avenue [phone]. I haven't been in this location but have dined in the Toronto restaurant several times - very good, but all ala carte and may over run your budget. Try the gigantic porterhouse for 2 . They serve it tableside, and carve it for you.....

The Don Shula's at the Westin Times Square is "average", but very cool decor if you're a football fan.

[foodismylife]

GREAT GREAT BONE IN RIB STEAK AN EXPERIENCE NOT TO BE MISSED

-----
Sammy's Roumanian
157 Chrystie St, New York, NY 10002

[egit]

Oh it's an experience alright. But the food isn't very good... and definitely not the steak. You're paying for a lot of schmaltz (literal and figurative) with Sammy's.

[fooder]

65 day dry aged ribeye from Primehouse NY. Spectacular, not overly expensive, good ambiance and location.

-----
Primehouse
381 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10016

[ESNY]

As I've said a bunch of times, all the top steakhouses in NY charge around the same price, about $35-$40 per person just for steak (literally a steak on a plate). Then figure around $8-10 for sides.
My favorite ribeye is at BLT Prime (get it without the butter on top).

-----
Blt Prime
111 E 22nd St Ste Frnt, New York, NY 10010

[mclaurie]

You might like to read this

http://newyork.seriouseats.com/2009/0...