HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >

Discussion

Can you help me remember the name of these cookies?

  • 9

I used to get sandwich cookies. They were vanilla flavored and had a hole in the middle. Anybody have any idea what they are called?

I thought they were hydrox...but does Hydrox just refer to the chocolate sandwich cookie?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Hmmm....your question intrigues me. I remember Butter Rings (flat unfilled butter cookies with a hole) and, for better words, the vanilla Hydrox - like an all-vanilla Oreo - but a filled vanilla with hole eludes me. Are you sure you're not getting the two above confused?

    Manufacturing a filled ring cookie seems complicated considering you need the two contiguous flat cookie surfaces to compress the filling evenly. Then, maybe not.

    You got me on this one.

    CP

    1 Reply
    1. re: Chefpaulo

      The filling would hang over part of the hole and I used to eat that part first. I think they came in a light blue bag...but I am not 100% sure about that part.

    2. Fudgetown? The original were all chocolate, but they had a "vanilla" version with fudge filling. Definitely a hole in the middle thru which the "fudge" poked out sorta' like a belly button. Made by the long gone Burry's of back east.

      1 Reply
      1. Fudge-O had a golden version for a while - called fudge-o golden - which of course makes no sense. Also I remember one from Pepperidge Farm but it was a golden cookie with a chocolate filling.

        1. Sorry...not Fudge-Os...

          Those sound tasty though.

          1. I remember having these ccokies for a snack in kindergarden. There would be a little bit of the vanilla filling that would squish out through the little hole. I think that these were fairly generic cookies. I have seen similar things in the supermarket in recent years, and TJ has a cookie called Joes that has a remarkably similar taste -- at least according to MY sense memory!