Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Oct 7, 2009 08:09 AM

Best place for fries and ice cream, together!

This should be an easy one, but you would not believe the soggy, overcooked fries, and the saccharine sweet ice cream that I've delved into lately.

So now I'm on a quest for one of my favorite things in the world; crispy, thin fries dipped into creamy, (not too sweet) ice cream. Salty. Sweet. Crispy. Creamy. How can you go wrong?

The only thing that has come close thus far is shake shack, but we all know what the lines are like there!

Any suggestions? (Around the east village would also be awesome)

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The original comment has been removed
    1. Clinton Street Baking Company has very good fries and excellent ice cream. I had both (separately, however) last week. With the ice cream, I can highly recommend the black and white cake and the apple pie -- both were fresh and delicious.

      1. interesting combination. i'm not sure i've tried fries n ice cream but fries and honey are great. (discovered at my Mcikey D days, long long ago.) you could grab the pommes frites and then go to Gem Shop for a scoop or a milkshake even if you like that consistency, but the pommes frites are not shoestring style but rather thick cut.

        12 Replies
        1. re: windycity

          Yeah, my first thought was Pommes Frites and the Van Leuwen truck which is oftentimes right there nearby, but if you have to have shoestring then I am not sure what to tell you.

          1. re: a213b

            Yeah, you know I have to say that I was kinda disappointed by Pommes Frites. The rosemary garlic mayo I got was outstanding, but the fries were greasy and all fell apart in my then greasy little hands!

            Have you guys tried cup and cones around the corner there on.... 9th st. (I think)? That place is pretty good.

            This is my original dilemma though... By the time you get the fries to the ice cream, the fried are cold. By the time you get the ice cream to the fries, the ice cream has melted!!! What's a girl to do?

            1. re: C Elise

              I understand what you're saying, though I will say I've only had one subpar experience at Pommes Frites out of the numerous times I've had them. And I know this past weekend the Van Leeuwen truck was literally parked right in front of it, so there'd be no concerns over the fries being too cold or the ice cream melting. I mean ... it was 5 steps from door to truck!

              1. re: C Elise

                Sundaes & Cones?

                Sundaes and Cones
                95 E 10th St, New York, NY 10003

                1. re: kathryn

                  Yes! The pistachio, hazelnut combo I got was gooooood.

                  I have to say that I've tried the Van Leeuwen truck; I tried the mint chocolate chip, and I was really, really sad because I was kinda disappointed and I really, really didn't want to be.

                  1. re: C Elise

                    Yeah ... I didn't love the mint chocolate chip either, but I figured that was due to being spoiled by my wife's AMAZING version she does at home.

                    Sad to hear the rest of it doesn't work out ... I will definitely have to try Sundaes and Cones ... we've walked by it several times and I always note it.

                    BTW, if you're disappointed by Van Leuwen, please for the love of all things good run away from the Big Gay Ice Cream Truck. Maybe I was expecting too much, but it's basically Mr. Softee soft-serve with store-bought toppings. Knowing it had been nominated for a Vendy I cannot even begin to describe my disappointment when I finally tried it.

                    So sad ...

                    1. re: a213b

                      I haven't really seen the Big Gay Ice Cream Truck described as anything BUT Mr. Softee with custom toppings.

                      I've had the Salty Pimp: canilla ice cream, dulce de leche, sea salt, dipped into chocolate. It was pretty good!

                      1. re: kathryn

                        i think it's about expectations - Van Leuwen's markets itself as upscale organic ice cream, and doesn't deliver IMHO. It's crumbly, the texture is off, there's not a great mouthfeel and probably not enough fat content for me. Big Gay Ice Cream truck is Mr. Softee with fun toppings in a fun truck. I don't expect the superlative.

                        1. re: windycity

                          Oh I agree ... like I said my expectations were far too high. Not having read about it I was expecting something more like artisanal ice cream with inventive toppings and such.

                          It's fun, but perhaps because I didn't grow up on Mr. Softee I don't have the same appreciation, because it tastes like terrible soft serve to me.

                          I was also bummed because, there's nothing done there that I cannot do at home. It's all store bought.

                          Again, for me it was just a matter of having the wrong idea about what it would be.

                          And I agree with you about VL ... not nearly as good as hyped, but when I suggested it it was only in an effort to provide the OP with a means to fulfill her desire for hot fries with cold ice cream.

                2. re: C Elise

                  Just wanted to let you know I had Pommes Frites tonight and they were fantastic. Nice and pillowy interior with a bit of a crispy crunch on the exterior. Had the Roasted Garlic and the Mango Chutney sauces (with a side of Jalapenos) and they were deee-lish!

                  They were not greasy at all, and really stood up, so maybe when you went they had an off night?

                  1. re: a213b

                    They definitely have off nights. I've noticed the fries aren't as great on nights with high humidity. The best sauce is the mango mayo.

              2. re: windycity

                I TOTALLY know what you're talking about with the honey and Mickey D's fries...

              3. OK, I remember Stand having some good shakes (toasted marshmellow) but the fries did not leave an impression. But you might give them a try....

                3 Replies
                1. re: JMJD

                  The fries there are super thin and crispy -- probably not strong enough to dip into ice cream.

                  1. re: kathryn

                    Love their sweet potato fries! Not at all soggy.

                    1. re: uwsister

                      Oooh, Stand has sweet potato fries? Somehow the ice cream hasn't been enough of a draw but I am a sucker for good sweet potato fries. The best I've had have been shoestring cut.

                2. You have to get a large fries and chocolate shake at McDonalds and dip the fries in the shake. Its the best combination of salty and sweet. Dont get too fancy on this one, go old school.

                  4 Replies
                  1. re: princeofpork

                    oh definitely! i'm a fan or the fries with a hot fudge sundae though...but yeah old school is the way to go

                    1. re: kelea

                      I agree with the Fries and Hot Fudge Sundae!

                      1. re: davisready

                        I used to stick a fry in the straw and drink the shake. How good is that?

                      2. re: kelea

                        Yes! That's what I'm talking about!!! But- not sure if I could bring myself to tromping into Mickey D's. Surely there's got to be somewhere better than that!