HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >


Sudden Inexplicable Craving for a Banana Split

It does seem odd, but I really want one.

I could go to Dairy Queen, but I'd like something a bit more upscale.

Not a big desserts guy, so I have no idea which ice cream shoppes in town offer this. Would prefer to sit in the space and eat, not try and transport it around somewhere else.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
    1. I like Caffe Demetre for decadent ice-cream things-and-stuff. They have several Toronto locations. Unfortunately, they also have a hugely annoying web site so I'm not bothering to link.

      2 Replies
      1. re: Rabbit

        Wouldn't matter if you had linked.

        "Why Can't I see the inside contents of your menu?

        Due to world-wide internet piracy, we have no other alternative but to limit the actual contents of our menu selections to protect our trademark and other proprietary marks. "

        Still, they are convenient to me, so maybe I will start there. I think I will do a once a weekend banana split tour and post results somewhere.

        1. re: Pincus

          found these on google image search

      2. http://www.dutchdreams.ca/product.asp...

        Dutch Dreams is totally delicious. I loved the ice cream there and the banana split was honestly one of the most awesome things I've had. Enjoy.

        4 Replies
          1. re: Pincus

            I've never seen an eating area at Dutch Dreams, do they have one?

            1. re: deelicious

              Yup, beyond the counter there's a little seating area.

        1. i love banana splits and have yet to find a good one.

          so far the most satisfying has been sicilian sidewalk cafe.

          oddfellows and tom's dairy freeze we're totally disappointing.

          honeslty though, i think i'd prefer a dairy queen one to those.

          1. i'd try coldstone creamery. i noticed it on the menu, it would likely be very yummy.

            1. I haven't had it, but Green Earth Cuisine has a Thai Banana Rolls dessert that seems yummy. It's served with vegan ice cream. Okay, on the face or it, this might not sound appealing, but I saw the dessert on someone's table last week, and it looked good. Might be a more sophisticated version of the DQ.

              3 Replies
              1. re: merlot143

                Some may call me a 'plebe' but I have had a couple of amazing Banana Splits at a couple of Baskin Robins..........pralines & cream, peanut butter & chocolate as the base and easy on the whipped cream (yuck..canned stuff, tolerable in very small amounts only). I only do this once or twice a summer...and then I take my 'lipitor'!!!

                1. re: pearlD

                  Baskin-Robbins serves some of the most obscenely caloric ice cream concoctions around...

                  1. re: pearlD

                    No Baskin Robbins makes incredible ice cream creations. They have perfected it. Their chocolate sauce is second to none! Also what makes even sweeter (hilarious pun) is that a couple times a year they give out coupons and the best deals are for the bigger concoctions- usually 2 for 1. I'm a fan. A Big fan.

                    Not sure if you wanted to ever make build one at home but PC's jarred chocolate sauce is actually delightful. (I think I like it because it tastes like Baskin Robbins).

                2. I have had many a BS at Dennys...basic but satisfies the cravings when they attack. BR is strictly okay...I prefer Licks-they make theirs a bit more wholesome...with trail mix and real fresh fruits. Good Luck!

                  1. Just noticed that Harbour 60 has a $16 banana split on their current dessert menu. Has anyone tried it?

                    Harbour Sixty
                    60 Harbour Street, Toronto, ON M5J 1B7, CA