Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Pennsylvania >
Sep 25, 2009 12:12 PM

great food in New Hope?

Hi all,

Apologies if this has already been covered, I tried to search for New Hope on this board but not much was coming up. My husband and I are thinking of taking a long, relaxing weekend trip to New Hope, from NYC (first real trip without Baby). But we are only interested if we can find some places with great food. Can anyone recommend a stellar place for dinner (price is not a concern)? A google search came up with La Bonne Auberge, but the menu looks a little old fashioned. That would be fine, if the food was really amazing. Any other fine dining ideas? The food is more important than the atmosphere. Recs can be a few miles from New Hope as we will have a car. Also looking for casual breakfast and lunch spots.
Thank you very much!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Try expanding your seach in the Pennsylvania secion for "Doylestown" or "Bucks County" - there has been a fair amount of discussion here.

    Also, across the river in Lambertville NJ.

    1. Coming from NYC, the bar for "great food" is set pretty high, and you might end up disappointed in the best that Bucks Co. has to offer. That said, there are a few places that offer wonderful ambiance and pretty darned good food. "Stellar" food, though...? Folks from NYC don't usually come to New Hope for the food. But if you do come, my dinner recommendation would be the Inn at Phillips Mill, just up the river from New Hope. Oh, and it's BYO, so check out the menu before you leave home and shop for your wine in NYC.

      1. I would go across the river to Lambertville. No. 9 is a very good byob there. Also Hamilton Grill (not byob).

        1. Post - or browse - on the Mid-Atlantic Board.
          There have been quite a few recommendations for places in New Jersey, across the river from New Hope, that sound really good.
          I don't think you will find what you want in New Hope itself.

          1. I'm not sure what you consider "stellar" food; Daniel, Gramercy Tavern or ?? In New Hope you're not going to get phenomenal food of that calibur, but what semi-rural place does? But you will find some good food and the New Hope area and it being your first time away from the baby will make it very pleasureable and memorable.

            On the PA side Inn at Phillips' Mill is probably the best. Kind of buttoned-down in a country inn sort of way, but the food is good and the BYOB is a big plus, to me at least. They have a fireplace in the dining area and the rooms upstairs are nice. My wine and dinner group of six couples had an overnight there a few years ago and we all liked it. It was raining so we couldn't go for a canal walk, so we went to Sandcastle Winery up the road. IMO, La Bonne Auberge is very good, but it's as you described, traditional fine French cuisine.

            In Lambertville NJ Hamilton's Grill Room is pretty good and it is also BYOB. They use high quality ingredients and prepare it well. Nothing really inventive but it's a really nice atmosphere and reasonably quiet. FWIW I believe the New York Times gave it two stars, but that was many years ago. If you want a before- or after-dinner drink there's a small bar across the way and it has character out the wazoo.

            I was disappointed by No. 9. Had their signature braised short ribs as I've made better at home. Also credibly loud. Another place right next door to No. 9 was also recommended, but the food was not well prepared and was over priced.

            My recommendation is go with Phillips or Hamilton, buy some great wine in Lambertville, and enjoy the experience as opposed to focusing too much on stellar food.

            1 Reply
            1. re: george2

              I didn't know Hamilton's was byob. Have to try it. Thanks.