HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >


Looking for Lyle's Golden Syrup

I think this basically explains itself. I am looking to make a treacle tart, but of course this can't be sans treacle. I have called up a few places in the Boston area but in truth I have no idea where I would find it to do this effectively. Any suggestions? Also, if it is in fact impossible to find it in Boston, advice would be appreciated about ordering it online. Thanks.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Check the UK goods in any Star/Shaw's or Stop & Shop. Russo's in Watertown also always has it, though it can be tricky to find (it's currently on the shelves under fruit displays, at the very front of the store facing the cashiers, near chocolate bars.)

    1 Reply
    1. re: Allstonian

      Specifically, it is on the lowest shelf under the peaches facing the express lane, as of this afternoon.

      If you have any other reason to go to Russo's, it's worth buying your Lyle's there, as it's consistently cheaper there than I've seen it anywhere else.

    2. I usually buy Lyle's at either Stop & Shop or Shaw's. It used to be in the international aisle with British foods, but have seen it lately in the sugar aisle near honey. The plastic bottles are all I buy now, but if you search some places still carry cans of golden syrup.

      1. Last time I got it, I got it at Roche Bros. I think it was near the molasses on the regular grocery shelves.

        1. Yes, Shaw's in Porter Square. Also British Delights on Power Road in Weston.

          1. shaw's has an around-the-world aisle (or some such nonsense name) and have seen lyle's there, even at my eastie location.

            1. Definitely check either above the honey in the baking aisle or in the "International" aisles of a larger Stop & Shop or Shaw's. I don't think they have the squeezable bottles, but have them in small green, black and white tins.

              6 Replies
              1. re: LindaWhit

                Those squeezy bottles are sacrelige, if surprisingly convenient. Tins FTW.

                1. re: chickendhansak

                  Well, to my defense, I ordered two squeezy bottles of Golden Syrup from an Aussie online site a LONG time ago, before it was ever carried in stores near me. They weren't carrying the tins, IIRC.

                  Why are they sacrilege?

                  1. re: LindaWhit

                    Just because they're traditional and the squeezy bottles are new (or perhaps made for the export-only market, I don't know). But part of the experience has always been watching it drizzle off a knife that you use after prising the stuck lid open, something you don't get with those well designed bottles.

                    Chow tip -- try GS on pancakes (crepe-style) for 1970s perfection.

                    1. re: chickendhansak

                      I specifically bought it to make ANZAC biscuits, but have used it in place of honey or molasses in savory cooking as well.

                  2. re: chickendhansak

                    Last time I bought a tin I swear I tasted a bit of a metallic flavor. So I switched to the squeeze bottles... Either way, the stuff is addictive and amazing. It is to sweet what Sriracha is to spicy.

                    Try making a pecan pie with it sometime. It leaves corn syrup far, far behind.

                    1. re: davis_sq_pro

                      pecan pie was what I first used Lyle's for - and I agree with you!


                2. Thanks everyone. I guess I will have to check myself since I actually had called the Shaw's and also the Stop and Shop near me and both denied carrying the product. I suppose in their defense not many people call them asking for it.

                  1. I'm looking for it too. Last I checked it was in my kitchen baking cabinet. Seriusly though. I got it at S and S South Bay, some time ago. You need to look where there is a large UK population.

                    1. I got it at WF in Bedford, in the baking aisle. Should be available in all of the them.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: missbidon

                        Yes, WFM at Fresh Pond in Cambridge almost always has it. I use it more during the holidays and always find it there. And if you call, the uber-nice WFM people will be happy to tell you if it's there now!


                      2. Try British Delights in Westford. Many other places carry it.


                        1. try Marty's in Newton.

                          Marty's Liquors
                          675 Washington St, Newton, MA 02458

                          1 Reply
                          1. re: okra

                            I saw it in Marty's last week. It's on the bottom shelf of the rack with honeys and maple syrups.