HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >
What's your latest food quest? Tell us about it
TELL US

Who is eating at the Mandarin?

t
toronto guy Sep 11, 2009 06:04 PM

Any readers eating at the Mandarin chain?

What are you enjoying?

What are you avoiding?

Are all locations created equal?

Thanks in advance

TG

  1. l
    lamaranthe Sep 17, 2009 10:51 AM

    Enjoying: Seafood and desserts
    Avoiding: Soups, salads and anything with strange colors.
    I only tried the Y&Eg location

    1. l
      lamaranthe Sep 17, 2009 10:41 AM

      Check http://www.mandarinbuffet.com/events.asp -- They are having the Moon Festival from Sept. 8 to October 25. IMO this is the place for very hungry people or for those who like to sample. Nothing 'chic' or sophisticated but a fun place for family and groups.

      1. p
        Pincus Sep 16, 2009 07:41 AM

        I will go when greed overcomes gourmet sensibilities. For what it is, it's not too bad.

        1. Davwud Sep 14, 2009 05:37 AM

          We just had one open up in Newmarket. It's very popular and as such, the turn over on food is really good. It's not the best Chinese food (as everyone has pointed out) but IMHO there are a lot worse places you could go for a lunch or dinner. It's especially good if the whole family is going. My dad has a very narrow window of what he'll eat and my mom is only slightly more open to new things. My younger sister and her family are as non adventurous as any one. That leave me, Mrs. Sippi, my older sister and her family. We're all willing to try a bunch of new things and in fact, as a good hound, if I hear of something new I'll go give it a shot. But sometimes you have to do the family thing.

          As for what's good, well, if crab legs are on they're good. I don't mind the sushi too much and most of the other stuff is standard. Egg rolls, chicken balls, chow mein's, etc.

          DT

          3 Replies
          1. re: Davwud
            JamieK Sep 15, 2009 05:51 PM

            As a veteran of a few family birthday gatherings at the Mandarin at Kipling and Queensway, I agree. Mandarin is ideal for those mixed-taste, multi-generational group things. Little kids love it. Teens love it. Older folks are comfortable. Everyone can find something they like. The food is pretty good. The service is great. And for those complaining about greasy food, I found the steamed vegetables there done perfectly.

            1. re: JamieK
              Sooeygun Sep 16, 2009 06:39 AM

              Completely agree JamieK. Have been to a few multi-gen family gatherings at Mandarin. My father likes to tell the grandkids that they don't have to eat main course, they can start with dessert (which I actually think is the worst part of the Mandarin buffet). And I can find enough things to fill a couple of plates.

              1. re: Sooeygun
                Jacquilynne Sep 16, 2009 09:11 AM

                In general, I don't like their desserts, but they have this lemon layer cake that I just can't help myself from liking. It's really light and really lemony and though I'm sure it's not really high up there on the quality scale, it's irresistible to me.

          2. c
            coco_t Sep 12, 2009 05:31 PM

            I'm 100 per cent Chinese and I can tell you that the "Chinese food" being served at Mandarin is not entirely authentic. Their food is totally Americanized and mostly fried. There are so many options in GTA if you're up for real Chinese cuisine.

            1 Reply
            1. re: coco_t
              p
              piccola Sep 13, 2009 06:46 PM

              I think most people realize that and only go to the Mandarin for good old "Canadian Chinese" food. But surely something there tastes good...

            2. Jacquilynne Sep 12, 2009 03:26 PM

              I eat there occasionally when I'm feeling nostalgic for the utterly crappy chinese smorgasboard food of my youth. If what you want is strictly americanized chinese food -- lots of deep fried things in sweet, cornstarch based sauces -- then Mandarin is a decent, clean, generally fresh rendition of it.

              The busier locations and busier times offer better turnover, and thus fresher food. If there isn't at least a small line when you go in, it's probably not your best choice -- you're either there at the wrong time or at the wrong Mandarin.

              1. p
                perogy Sep 12, 2009 08:39 AM

                I don't go there anymore - ever. I do agree that it is a safe place for chinese food, b/c it is bland and appeals to all tastes.

                My real complaint with this place is the propensity for cross contamination. I canot eat any fish or seafood due to allergies, but it is not so bad that I can't frequent places where it is served. The problem comes when the kitchen or in this case, other diners, do not take care to keep the utensils in the dish they belong.

                I had the unfortunate experience of being there during a crab fest - and they put the two crab trays directly beside the two noodle and rice dishes that were vegetarian. People, in their MADNESS to get at the crab (I am looking at the poster who commented on his in-laws stalking the crab/lobster station for refills) would just take the noodle spoons and dip them right into the crab tray.

                This is annoying and gross and I don't even want to get into the pain that it was to complain: they didn't care (or staff didn't get it).

                I will definately never go back, especially because I have heard that the crab is now 24/7. No more specials, it's there every day.

                People are vultures! It's all you can eat. The food isn't going anywhere, right?

                1 Reply
                1. re: perogy
                  BamiaWruz Sep 12, 2009 11:12 AM

                  Perogy, wow, that's a terrible experience to go through. Did you break out? I hope not.

                  I'm shocked that they didn't even do something about it. My significant other is allergic to all seafood but we go there whenever family wants to go and he's been careful too but thankfully no breakouts as of yet.

                  We should probably avoid it from now on, he's super paranoid (which is good of course) but something as you described above is not easily avoided.

                  As for the vulture comments, I absolutely agree. Whenever I go I find it more interesting to watch the people than actually eat.

                2. BamiaWruz Sep 12, 2009 03:07 AM

                  Not all locations are the same, some are better than others. Overall it's not that great, very ordinary.

                  Everytime I go I find less and less that I actually like, that it seems to be a waste because for the price I could go out and find something a lot better.

                  Locations I've enjoyed more than others, whitby, pickering, heard that thornhill was good. Burlington was to be avoided, check restaurantica, the reviews there can help. Newer or newly opened locations seem to be better usually (for a while)

                  1. f
                    FrankD Sep 11, 2009 07:53 PM

                    The Mandarin is a "safe" choice for people who aren't sure they like Chinese food. Nothing too exotic, lots of deep fried stuff you can cover with bright red or yellow sauce, stir fries that don't contain exotic ingredients, etc. Plus, there are plenty of western choices at both their carving station, and at the salad bar. So, if you have grand parents who want to "try" Chinese but don't want to get too far out of their comfort zone, Mandarin is a good choice.

                    Even my Chinese in-laws go from time to time, but only when crab or lobster is on special, and then one of them will hang out by that station, and bring back a huge plate every time it gets restocked.

                    Avoid the soups - if they're not bland, they're horrid. Most of the other stuff is passable. Some of the prepared salads taste strange at times, like they've been out too long, so I usually get a small sample first to see.

                    Only been to the Markham and Y&E locations - can't say there's much to choose between them.

                    Overall - prefer China Buffet King.

                    Show Hidden Posts