HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Cookie help

elfcook Sep 7, 2009 03:36 PM

My kids (and I) love snickerdoodles. I have a tried and true recipe, and they taste great. The problem is that once they cool completely, they are hard as rocks. We zap them in the microwave for a few seconds & they are great, but I want to know WHY they get so hard and how to avoid this problem. I store them in ziploc bag (for the short time they last around the house), but they seem to get hard almost immediately. What am I missing?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Emme RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 04:41 PM

    several things to consider...

    how is your fat to sugar ratio? you might consider increasing your fat to retain more moisture. a lesser ration, meaning more sugar to butter will produce a flatter, crisper cookie.

    are you using all white sugar? if so, you might try subbing in some brown sugar. if you're already using some brown, increase that and decrease the white by some accordingly. brown sugar produces a chewier, softer cookie.

    you can also try pulling the cookies out of the oven early, say by five minutes, depending how long you're cooking them, then allow them to sit on the cookie sheet. they'll continue to cook, but i find they stay softer longer.

    storage tricks: try putting a piece of bread into the storage container - the bread will get hard, and the cookies will stay softer. some also store in plastic ziploc bags... i usually never have a problem with the tupperware containers, but you might try ziploc first.

    maybe report back on your recipe, so we can give you more focused feedback...

    1 Reply
    1. re: Emme
      enbell RE: Emme Sep 7, 2009 05:56 PM

      Yes, manipulate the white:brown sugar ratio. Reduce the white I'd say 1/4 c at a time and replace with brown until you arrive at the desired texture.

    2. chowser RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 05:10 PM

      My first thought would be you left them in the oven too long. They need to be slightly underdone when you take them out (they continue cooking), cool on the tray a couple of minutes and remove to a cookie rack. If they're fully cooked coming out of the oven, they'll be hard when they cool. If they are hard the next day, add a piece of bread to the container and it'll soften them, as Emme recommended.

      1. elfcook RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 05:34 PM

        thanks for the help. I do take the cookies out a bit underdone - I like them that way! They are soft at first, not a thin, crisp cookie to begin with. I will try subbing brown sugar for part of the white sugar, and the bread tip. Just more excuses for "test batches" I guess :)

        1 Reply
        1. re: elfcook
          theferlyone RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 06:27 PM

          I use a 2 to 1 ratio of brown to white in most cookie recipes with consistently chewy results. I also melt the butter...I don't know if that will help with this problem specifically, but it makes for a tasty cookie. Good luck!

        2. greygarious RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 06:27 PM

          Get them onto a cooling rack right away - if you line the pan with parchment you can remove the whole sheet to the rack and not have to remove soft cookies with a spatula.

          1. iluvcookies RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 06:55 PM

            You can try melting the butter... this trick works for my choc chip cookies. Got the technique from Cook's Illustrated and the cookies stay soft when stored at room temp in an airtight container for a couple of days. Using brown sugar helps as well.

            1. s
              SonyBob RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 07:42 PM

              The bread trick works great.
              Bob

              1. Emme RE: elfcook Sep 7, 2009 08:12 PM

                one more thought... try chilling the dough before baking. less spreading will help a chewier, less flat crisp cookie. i know the problem isn't when they're first baked, but it might help in the longer run too. just a thought!

                Show Hidden Posts