Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Sep 2, 2009 07:43 PM

Yerba Buena Perry or Novita?

Two of us are coming from out of town for Labor Day weekend (SF and Boston), and looking forward to a dinner with great friends we rarely get to see. Through a bit of research on this board, I have made reservations for a party of 10 at both Yerba Buena Perry and Novita this Saturday night. As much as I wish I could go to both, we have to pick one.

Yerba Buena has an interesting menu, and it seems like it would be a fun place to have dinner, but we're a bit worried it would be too loud for conversation. I've heard good things about Novita, but I'm a little worried it will be a bit of an older crowd. We're in our late-20's/early 30's, and by no means are looking to eat in a hopping club, but we also don't want to feel like we need to speak in hushed voices. Food is key, but so is atmosphere.

If you had to go to one of these, which would you choose?

Thank you!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Yerba Buena literally just opened last week, not sure much useful feedback you're going to get.

    Friends who went last weekend said the place was empty on a Friday night. But, then again, it had just opened.

    1. You could try the Yerba Buena on the lower east side...excellent food. although a bit small for 10.

      1. While I had a lovely first-time-experience at Novita, my second was more dismal (service-wise). I wasn't as impressed with the food as I was on the first go-around. That being said, the space is lovely, but it's definitely not somewhere I'd like to reconnect with a group of 10 friends (20's and 30's). The atmosphere is a bit "older" and calmer.
        I've not been to either of the Yerba Buena locations, but I've heard wonderful things. I'm a big fan of Julian Medina, and have followed him since his days at Zocalo.
        Good luck with your decision! Enjoy your holiday weekend here. :)

        1. The original comment has been removed
          1. The original comment has been removed