HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >


Toaster vs. Toaster Oven

I can't decide. I don't have enough counter space for both! I have an old toaster oven that has slowly broken down. I mostly use it for toast, melting cheese on things (one of my favorite pastimes!) and toasting nuts. The toast never comes out so great, and I could probably use the broiler for the other things...and yet, I like having a toaster oven. I know I'm lucky if this is my biggest dilemma in life. Seriously, I've bought cars with less consideration than this!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. stick with the toaster oven for versatility - you can do some research to find one that produces good toast.

    1. I only have enough space for one also. I went for the toaster oven because of it can do so many things. It is nice to use it for one or two baked potatoes rather than heat up a big oven.
      I also love cheese melted over an open faced sandwich. Toast is better in a toaster though. If I ate toast frequently I may have made a different decision.

      There are some toaster ovens that install under your cabinets - perhaps that option would allow both?

      1. Sounds like you already have your mind made up with the leaning toward the toaster oven. And so far, others support that leaning as a good idea. I don't. Especially in a smallish kitchen, and if you have other ways to melt cheese.

        The thing I hate about toaster ovens is that, in reality, they take up twice the counter space as their "footprint" simply because you have to keep the area in front of them clear so you can open the door. I've always found that a huge pain. And, like you, none of the toaster ovens I've ever owned did a half way decent job of toasting anything. And the biggest pain of all is that I've never had or seen a toaster oven that turns the toast over and toasts the other side without intervention from me! Such a drag!

        Instead, I have a GE "Classic Toaster" that does four slices at a time, has little "holders" that grab the bread when it is lowered and holds it at an even and optimum position for toasting. I can push a button and it will toast only the cut side of a bagel if I have it loaded right, it will defrost those breakfast thingies that are filled and that you drizzle icing over after they're heated/toasted. It also has a button to push to "Reheat." I have no idea what the difference between "Defrost" and "Reheat" is as I've never used either one. I'm quite happy with one sided and two sided toasting.

        To melt cheese or pre-buttered or olive oil drizzled whatever, I do that either in my built-in microwave using the halogen heat source without microwave, or I can use my oven. Or I can use a creme brulee torch (as in large industrial sized butane torch that plumbers use to solder copper pipes). Hey, it's fast and I have control!

        But most of all, I love being able to leave my sugar bowl sitting in front of my toaster and not have to give a thought to breaking it when I open the damned door!

        8 Replies
        1. re: Caroline1

          Caroline1, I do not argue with you but in the instance of safety. You do note that you need to have clearance room in front of a toaster oven for the door. That is true. However, you really need to be careful around regular toasters as well - the little toasters don't look like much but they get really hot an can melt/burn things around them. I just don't want to see something get ruined/someone get hurt thinking you don't need space around them. Our coffee pot in the office has a few "melty" looking spots and it sits right next to the toaster.

          I do personally use a toaster oven though. As much as i would like to get rid of it I do find it hard to justify turning on a full size range to melt cheese on one piece of toast for myself. I should be getting an over the range micro/convection oven installed Monday though so it is possible that I will use that at times but I will have to see what it works best as. Most people don't have that option though.

          1. re: Allice98

            i have to agree with Allice here. i would never turn on my full-size oven & waste that kind of energy to toast a pice of bread, heat up a single potato, or melt some cheese - that's just crazy talk IMHO...and if you want to melt the cheese over something toasty, the MW isn't an option because it'll turn your lovely, crisp toast or bread soft & soggy in seconds. i've used my toaster oven for everything from toast and baked potatoes to broiled fish and meat. it's definitely the better choice unless the only thing you'll ever use it for is toast.

            1. re: goodhealthgourmet

              I never said I would use my full oven for a slice of toast. I said that I can melt cheese in my Advantium oven using halogen light, but I did refer to it as my "built in microwave," but indeed it is so much more. It cooks by halogen light OR microwave OR both. And -- hypothetical here -- if it uses twice the power of a toaster oven (I have no idea if that's true) it does melt the cheese on top, and if I want it to it will crisp the bottom at the same time, so I would only have to use ithalf the time of a toaster oven if I wanted bread toasted on the bottom and cheese melted on the top. It's an extremely efficient and handy appliance!

              1. re: Caroline1

                fair enough...but most of don't have a fancy-schmancy Advantium ;)

            2. re: Allice98

              No. I don't need any clearance room around my toaster. It has a lovely chrome housing, however the entire exterior of the toaster stays cool to the touch at all times. Well, unless I put my hand on top of it over the toast slots. There ARE some well designed toasters on the market these days. Child safe, even! '-)

            3. re: Caroline1

              I do most of my oven jobs in the toaster oven and it pleases me to think that I am saving energy. I even use it for cooking sweet potatoes and baking biscuits. I don't own a toaster anymore.

              1. re: Sharuf

                You need a Trivection oven! Really fast, really good. I will be cooking my 25 pound stuffed turkey in it this Thanksgiving when the whole family gathers, and the stuffed bird will be roasted to perfection in 2 hours and thirty minutes, which means I have to hustle to have the rest of the meal ready when the turkey is done. There really ARE some great user friendly appliances out there, folks! The Trivection will cook the turkey in that short a time using thermal heat, convection heat and microwave all at the same time and I will say I have never had jucier more flavorful turkeys in all of my life as I get with this oven.

                But for those times when I just want to use straight thermal heat, I have invested considerable money in converting my entire house to CFL and LED light bulbs, so when I need thermal oven, I use it in clear conscience. I'm not an energy squanderer.

            4. i have a toaster oven, because of the versatility. I use it to bake smaller items like an 8-in sq pan of brownies, to do gratins, tofu dishes, toast nuts, etc. What I DON'T use it for it toast! It does make lousy toast. But, unless you love toast and eat it alot, I'd go for the toaster oven. But if toast is your raison d'ĂȘtre for breakfast, go with the toaster.

              3 Replies
              1. re: nofunlatte

                I love toasted day old baguette for breakfast.... Maybe i am just a piggy, but, I can't possibly squeeze the two long halves into a toaster!

                1. re: Allice98

                  Time for an engineer to develop a new small appliance that I don't need but will want nonetheless! Didn't think of the baguette toasting issue. And no, you're not a piggy--but I think you should consider being a toast scientist and doing some more work on data collection. Perhaps you can think of other things to toast that the likes of a toast philistine like me could never conceive of!

                  1. re: nofunlatte

                    On the flip side you can't toast really small things in a toaster either.... if the edge is too short to stick out of the toasters opening you can't use it.

                    Not unless you want to turn the toaster upside down to get things out so that the crumbs fall all over the counter and onto the floor.

                    But, I wouldn't know a thing about it....... nope! Not I!

              2. I had the same dilemma. After daily use, the door to my 7 year old under-the-cabinet toaster oven had to be propped closed for it to work. A fire hazard, I thought. I have a tiny kitchen with no counter space at all. Like yours, it never really did toast all that great but it was very handy and I could broil a chicken leg or bake a couple of cookies without much hassle. I thought about replacing it, but the manufacturer changed the design of their under-the-counter models so I'd have to buy a whole new assembly for a lot more money. I ended up buying a regular toaster made by Cuisinart and I haven't looked back. It actually toasts on the first go.

                If I were you, I'd use the broiler in my oven for melting cheese and the like. As for nuts, I use a cast iron skillet on my stove for that.

                1. I love, love, love my toaster oven. I use it daily.

                  5 Replies
                  1. re: Janet from Richmond

                    I have to admit that when mine died, I didn't rush out and replace it. Soon my husband asked me to pick up a toaster next time I was out because a friend was flying back from NJ and was bring bagels and he HAD to have a toaster for the bagels....
                    I have since noticed that we eat more toast now-because the toaster oven didn't toast sliced bread for shit. I don't want to eat more toast- I need room for other goodies, not toast (because with toast comes slabs of butter and I don't need slabs of butter either!!)
                    I used to make fast roasted garlic in that toaster oven without heating up the big oven, and I've missed that....

                    1. re: Boccone Dolce

                      ooh, right! roasted garlic - the other use for which i find the toaster oven invaluable.

                      1. re: goodhealthgourmet

                        I have roasted it before in the crockpot... I take a mini 1 quart crockpot and do the usual foil up and oiling of the garlic. toss it in the slowcooker for the day.

                        Do it outside though if you can. there is definitely something to having it in there all day and it actually makes you cry... of course then and again i also use a lot of heads when i have done this. We LOVE garlic... but hubby banned this activity to the outside if I wasn't doing it in the oven. I actually agreed.

                        1. re: Allice98

                          i actually don't own a slow cooker...it's one of the few things on the list i need to get around to picking up one of these days :)

                          1. re: goodhealthgourmet

                            I have a lot - but I have to tell you I really do like having a few 1 quart ones around. They aren't soemthing that i use all the time but i really like being able to say make a sauce before I entertain, pop it in the small slow cooker and keep it on the warm setting without needing to stir and getting to clean up everything else. You still have to pay attention to things on the stove and check on them etc.

                            I know that I still have the now extra crock to wash alter as well but it really isn't a big deal to me because I don't have to worry about the "fill int he blank " later. And i can then spend time attending to something else last minute instead.

                            Or I can roast garlic!

                  2. We've got a Cuisinart convection toaster oven. First, it makes great toast. Beyond that it's big enough for a frozen pizza, it's great for roasting veggies, It's not cheap but since I use it all the time, it's a great value.

                    1. Well I'm enjoying this thread because I have neither appliance and I'd like to have some toast. In my experience, toaster ovens neither toast nor oven well. And, yes, I am aware that oven really isn't a verb.

                      Reading threads like this in the past have scared me off from both toasters and toaster ovens because of the fire hazard. Unfortunately, I have yet to mater toasting bread in a skillet.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: BeaN

                        Toasters really aren't that much of a fire hazard. I think there are some problems putting them under cabinets, but my cuisinart didn't have a problem with that. I can't deny the fire hazardness of the toaster oven as I did start a fire in mine. That was more because I had gotten it from somewhere else and had no idea it was like 3x the wattage as was given in the instructions. On the bright side, aside from looking slightly charred, the toaster oven still worked beautifully after the mishap.

                      2. I had both for years, and reclaimed some counter space by ditching the toaster oven. Since I made toast in the toaster oven for 90% of it's use, and was never happy with it, I decided to use my oven/broiler as the toaster oven, and use my toaster for some good toast.

                        1. DH was a firm believer in toaster ovens when we were married, and in fact, I received a monstrosity of a toaster/oven/broiler as a wedding gift. We used it until I could no longer stand giving up the counter space to it years later. It was a relief to toss it out.

                          It did make for a lot of jokes around here, however. For one thing, since toasting in a toaster oven that does not shut off automatically requires constant vigilance, I got a lot of mileage teasing him and his family members about how they watched their toast as though they were watching a television show each morning. They really did look silly, hunched over the hulking chrome waiting for the perfect "doneness" so that they could remove their toast in time.

                          What do we use now? A toaster, thank goodness. It is wide enough to hold thick rolls or bagels, and there is no need to stand over the thing. The bell is key -- and the primary reason I did not go with Dualit, which requires some vigilance too as a result.

                          Since I never really used the hulking chrome mass for much more than toast, or perhaps heating cold pizza, I don't miss it. For loaves of bread, whole rolls and pizza, I just put them on my pizza stone or on an oven rack and heat the oven. Little chance of burning, even when things are hectic in the kitchen, versus a greater chance of burning in the toaster/oven/broiler. If you use your gadget for more than toast, and don't want to or can't turn an oven on, then go toaster oven, and not toaster. For me, it was too much appliance.

                          One question, slighly off topic: What ever happened to the little toaster ovens that popped open and shut down when finished? I haven't seen one of those in a long time.

                          2 Replies
                          1. re: RGC1982

                            I definitely have to laugh over your description of watching to toast in the toaster. I know the settings well on my toaster oven so that I can leave it alone. This morning though I toaster a bagel in the work toaster. Something that i do about every 6 months here. I was watching it like a hawk, I kept popping the bagel up out of the toaster to look at it because I was afraid it was burning. I can tell you that if you had seen me your in-laws would have looked pretty normal to you!

                            Then because it was a Panera cinnamon crunch bagel when i put it on the paper plate to spread on the cream cheese all the sugar stuck to the plate and I had a really hard time prying it off. Because of being in the toaster it seriously melted the sugar and then welded itself to the plate. Being at work is so difficult some days!

                            1. re: Allice98

                              Well, toasters aren't perfect, but we've managed here with one or another for at least ten years and we're fine. I have to confess, though, that we usually don't have sugar on our bagels. Even the cinnamon raisin doesn't appear to have sugar on the outside, so I really have never experienced this.

                              Here's the thing: Not only don't I want to watch the toaster oven as it toasts, even I, a certified appliance junkie with acres of counter space, will not devote a couple of square feet to one. Maybe if I lived in dorm room or cooked at the office, I could see it, but there is no reason to do it in my kitchen. Heck, I've got two microwaves and two ovens, so it is not that I don't like gadgets -- I just don't really need this one. And I never want to watch it intently for a few minutes while it is toasting.

                          2. Except for toast fanatics, it's wasteful to pay money and give counter space to an appliance that's only good for toasting bread products and pop-up tarts. Like Alton Brown, I don't go for unitaskers, and a toaster oven is definitely a multitasker. But you shouldn't think of toaster ovens as toasters that can also do other things, they're small ovens that can also do toast.

                            The old-style toaster ovens - small front-to-back, lightweight, cheap - are very limited in what they can be used for. Larger, more versatile TOs are now being made even by Black & Decker, whose CTO6301 6-Slice Convection Toast-R-Oven sells for $67.19 on amazon.com.

                            1. I just bought one of these, and I'm totally chuffed with my new toy.
                              It's both a pop-up toaster AND a toaster oven - ingenious!

                              1. I cannot extoll the virtues of the breville smart oven enough. From simple toast to roasted vegetables, open face sandwiches, nachos and more. The convection and frozen options are great. Oh, and it makes incredible pizza.

                                1 Reply
                                1. re: M_Xandria

                                  Oh yes, I saw those - they look great. I also love all of the accessories that come with them.

                                2. eh another ancient thread revival.

                                  1 Reply
                                  1. re: rasputina

                                    Geez. If I'd started a new thread, it's "we've already got a gazillion threads on this". Can't please everybody.

                                  2. Old thread but kind of "immortal" topic. I wonder why people compare Toaster with Toaster oven as they have HUGE differences and no comparison according to me.

                                    Most Toaster oven (Like Breville BOV800XL, Breville BOV650XL http://www.toasterovenguide.com/brevi... ) is actually better because it can be used toasting bread, baking, reheating,broiling, fancy garlic bread. Yes, kitchen space , budget & electricity consumption are the important factors that affect your purchasing.

                                    1 Reply
                                    1. re: jamesneo05

                                      That's a really, really nice looking toaster oven. I still love the little one I got a few weeks ago, but my oven blew up last Friday so now I'm wishing I'd bought a slightly bigger one :/