Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Southern New England >
Aug 25, 2009 07:55 AM

Anniversary Seafood Restaraunt Fairfield/Westport Area?

So our 4th wedding anniversary is on Thursday and my wife has requested seafood. We live in Trumbull and would like a quick trip home after dinner - so we're looking in the Fairfield/Westport area. We used to love the Restaurant at Rowayton Seafood but want to try something new! I'd love to hear what you might suggest chowhounds!!!

Thanks in advance!


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Rowayton Seafood has a new chef and i actually think it's better than before.
    Do you need a seafood restaurant? if not, i've had great scallops and other pieces of fish at the schoolhouse. i can't think of a better place for an anniversary dinner.

    1 Reply
    1. re: LW1

      what about Paci -- more italian than seafood, but a true delight to go there --- and everything is delicious!

    2. Osianna. It's mediterranean with a strong seafood presence. Especially love the scallops and the stuffed shrimp.

      4 Replies
      1. re: Ima Foodie

        Rowayton is just a bit too far, I think.

        LOVE the Schoolhouse - we had Valentine's supper there.

        Paci - we had a REALLY bad experience a year or so ago. The service was the pits although the food wasn't too bad.

        Osianna was quite nice - i might consider that again...

        1. re: a_w_taylor

          Its been a while since I've been there, but you could add Splash in Westport to your list.

          1. re: amanda3571

            Splash is fun, but very loud and crowded, so if you are looking for a quiet romantic evening I wouldn't recommend it...but we were just there last week and had a nice dinner out on the deck. Crackling calamari salad...yum!

            I've been a big fan of Paci, been going there for about 14 years...but I have to say that I think the food has suffered since Maury, one of the chefs, left about a year ago. Still good food, but just not as delicious as it used to be. I've also had a couple of times recently where the portion size on my appetizer was ridiculously small...once it was grilled calamari on a bed of arugula...I kid you not, there was one body and one tentacle...that's it. I didn't see any other plates of it going out, so I don't know if that was the portion size or if they ran out and thought it would pass. The next time I had figs with prosciutto and mascarpone...there were 3 fig halves on the plate...a little strange!

            Osianna is nice...we always share the small plates and get a nice mix of different things, lots of seafood. The stuffed calamari is great.

            Schoolhouse is a favorite of ours, but the menu is so small there would probably only be one fish dish.

            1. re: amanda3571

              I had a great meal at Splash a couple of years ago -- extra points if you sit on the porch on a lovely late summer evening.

              Sad to hear Paci's service was subpar...I've been treated well when I've been there.

              I agree the Schoolhouse is a no-brainer. Local, fresh food with innovative combinations!


        2. What about Outrigger's at Brewer's Marina in Stratford? It has the view and ambiance for a special occasion from what I've read and from pictures I've seen. All I know, from a while back, was it was getting mixed reviews.
          Knapp's Landing? No personal knowledge.

          5 Replies
          1. re: Scargod

            Knapps Landing only good for the view and lob rolls. Way too casual and long in the tooth for a festive or romantic occassion. But great for lobster roll on the terrace on a sunny summer afternoon as the oyster boats ply the entrance of the Houstanic at the Sound.

            Agree about Splash in Westport. With knockout waterviews on the deck -- where the noise level is better than inside. I've had a couple of good meals there and it is a fun place to celebrate summer and the sound, as well as an anniversary.

            1. re: louuuuu

              Bingo! Splash is just what we were looking for! It doesn't really need to be quiet. I have a ressie on the deck for 7:30!

              Thanks for your help Chowhound'rs!!!



              1. re: a_w_taylor

                There is a side deck and a deckover looking the sound

                  1. re: allieb2031

                    I know this is way overdue, but I wanted to respond!

                    We ended up having a wonderful time/meal at Splash!