Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Aug 20, 2009 08:18 AM

Homemade pizza - some ideas and tips

I thought I'd share some of my ideas and tips for making home made pizza, which is something I've been doing every few weeks for the past two years.

Full-write up with pictures:

Quick summary:
-Use a good quality bread flour. I'm currently using King Arthur bread flour and it's wonderful.

-You really should use a good quality pizza stone to get that desired crisp crust and soft center. I got mine at a restaurant supply store for $50. The cheaper ones at Bed Bath and Beyond will shatter. I've broken two of those already.

-Preheat the oven at the highest setting for at least 45 mins. Don't assume the oven is ready when that light turns off, as the heat will continue to build up in the stone.

-About that dough -- if you're pressed for time, you can pick up prepared dough at Trader Joe's, but nothing beats the flavor and texture of home made. I'm using a dough recipe from Tyler Florence: (towards the bottom


-I use a two-rise process, where I let the dough rise in a warm place for two house, then punch and reshape it, and place in the fridge for another 1-2 days. This isn't necessary and the first rise will suffice (but that second rise yields a nicer final texture).

-Dough stretching and tossing. This is toughest part and I still screw up. Take the dough out of the fridge and let it come to room temperature. Then, place on a flour surface, form into a thick circle about 1" thick. Now pick up and hang vertically using both hands; rotate the pizza on its vertical axis using hand-over-hand action. Gravity will stretch the dough for you. Do this quickly and you'll have a near-perfect circle. Tossing isn't really necessary unless the dough is large.

-Don't sauce and top the pizza too far in advance of placing it in the oven, otherwise, the sauce and water from the ingredients will make the dough soggy, leading to soggy crust. It's best to prepare the pizza right before it goes into the oven

-Don't pile on too many ingredients. You want everything to cook, right?

-Cooking times vary, maybe 10 mins, and turn the pizza 180-degrees about half-way through.

-Let the pizza rest for a few minutes before slicing. Don't bother with a fancy roller cutter -- just use your largest chef or Santoku knife.

-The best part -- enjoy!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Thanks for the tips. I'll save this post in case I get ambitious. I usually just buy the dough from Trader Joe's refridgerator section.

    1 Reply
    1. re: LA Buckeye Fan

      Me too...and then I throw it on the grill.

    2. Try making your own starter or reducing the yeast in the TF recipe to just a pinch. You have got the rest of the details nailed. Long proofs make awesome flavors in your dough.

      1 Reply
      1. re: Brandon Nelson

        Brandon -- you're absolutely correct. I forgot to note that I cut back on the yeast, about .20oz on my scale versus the .25oz in most packets (I'm using dry instant from a jar). Thanks!

      2. I like to cook the crust for a minute or two before putting on the sauce, to prevent sogginess.

        17 Replies
        1. re: coll

          In college I bartended at one of Todd English's Figs restaurant. The pizza cook always told me to make sure that my dough was room temperature. And to make sure not to put too many toppings towards the middle. Because as it cooks, everything slides to the center of the pie.

          1. re: Stellar D

            That's a great idea, Stellar. I never thought of the room temperature factor applying to pizza dough, or everything moving to the center when it cooks.

            And I have a question, too. Back many years ago, I received as a gift a pizza stone with a polished surface. Most pizza stones have a singularly unpolished surface so that they can absorb moisture from the pizza and make the crust crisp. However, they also absorb tomato sauce, cheese, and grease. I loved my polished pizza stone, which seemed to make the crust plenty crisp but was one heck of a lot easier to clean.

            Alas, I dropped it about ten years ago and it shattered into a million pieces. Since then, I have been unable to find one. Does anyone know where I can find one?

            1. re: gfr1111

              unglazed quarry tiles aren't terribly porous, and might suit your needs.

              i would add that i've never had a problem with cleaning a pizza stone because they don't really need to be cleaned.

              1. re: gfr1111

                Check with a restaurant supply store in your area. You can also check out as they have the same stone I'm using.

                And when cleaning the stone, don't use use soap because it can be absorbed by the stone. Not good. A simple scraping/brushing of the surface is all I ever do.

                1. re: gfr1111

                  How would you get the final rise if it wasn't at room temp?

                  1. re: coll

                    Coll, the dough will still rise in the fridge but it will take longer. Sometimes I make the dough late at night, place in the fridge, then have my wife take out the dough next day around 2pm (if/when she works from home). Place the dough on a floured surface and cover with a dishtowel. It will be perfectly ready to stretch and toss in a few hours, as it will have come to room temp and softened up a bit. Hope that helps.

                    1. re: havepixel

                      That's what I do too, and if you don't take the dough out a couple of hours ahead you're not going to get a good final rise with the cool temp in the fridge. It's like a wet noodle. I'm just wondering why people didn't know about room temp, I can't imagine just taking it out and baking immediately.

              2. re: coll

                coll, I just started using a pre-bake method for pizza dough myself. Prefer it now.

                I rub the dough down with light olive oil, toss some dried basil & oregano and 2 crushed fresh garlic cloves and prebake for about 8 mins in a 500 degree oven. Then I add the sauce and cheese, toppings and bake til bubbly! This method does a wonderful job of crisping the crust top to bottom!

                1. re: HillJ

                  The dough definitely needs to sit out for a few hours--usually at least 2 hours so that you can easily stretch it without tearing. Putting toppings in the middle also helps keep them on the pizza when you slide and "snap" it into the oven.

                  1. re: havepixel

                    What kind of cheese do you use and sauce. I used to make pizza dough in my bread maker and then add random jar sauce with shredded mozza from the grocery store. Clearly, I need higher end productsbecause the effort was not worth the result. Can anyone give me brand names of good cheese and sauce or recipes that aren't too labor intensive bec ow Id rather just buy it, YKWIM?

                    1. re: lilmomma

                      Hi, I use Muir Glen organic tomato sauce which can be found at Whole Foods. Hunt's sauce is also good. The thicker consistency of these two sauces hold up well when applied to the dough; Muir Glen has a better taste IMO. I also add chopped rosemary and thyme and then pile on the cheese. As for the mozzarella, I've been using Sargento shredded mozzarella, or sometimes I'll buy a block of mozzarella from Whole Foods and shred it myself.

                      1. re: havepixel

                        Is the Muir Glen sauce a pizza sauce or just reg old tomato sauce?

                        1. re: lilmomma

                          Sorry I should have specified that. I use the regular tomato sauce. The pizza sauce is absolutely fine, but I prefer the taste of the tomato sauce with freshly-chopped herbs.

                          This is one:

                          This small can is enough for the three pizzas I posted in my blog. Hope that helps!

                      2. re: lilmomma

                        I don't use a spaghetti sauce, don't feel it needs it. I spoon about 3 ladelfuls of Pastene Kitchen Ready Sauce over my crust. And the cheese I use, is the fresh buffalo mozzarela that you find in the barrels at the grocer's. Just be sure to slice the cheese and let it drain on paper towels to get the moisture out. I liberally salt and pepper my whole pizza and drizzle with olive oil right before I place it in the oven also.

                        1. re: mcel215

                          What is Pastene Kitchen ready sauce?

                          1. re: lilmomma

                            It's a "crushed tomato" in a can. It really could be any good brand.

                            Instead of a cooked sauce, it's an easy topping that tastes really good on pizza right from the can.

                            But, Pastene "kitchen ready" may be just sold in New England.

                    2. re: HillJ

                      That's how I do my pizza also. The pre-baking also bakes in a great flavor to the crust.

                  2. Couple of comments.

                    1. Try adding some other flour, perhaps a higher protein one or a harder one. Makes a more interesting overall texture. You can also try a little whole wheat or rye.
                    2. The method for shaping pizzas taught me at the pizzeria is room temperature dough, then dimple it rapidly with your finger tips - all of them if you can - to flatten and then simply pick it up and turn over the backs of your hands. The dimpling has an effect. Key point is to cover with enough flour that you can move it around. Just shake off any excess.
                    3. A more weird trick is to bake one side lightly - until it firms but isn't browned - then pull out or flip and dress that firmed side. Then you can crank up the oven or fire and get the crust crispy without needing to cook the dough for so long that it burns.

                    And use less cheese than your instincts tell you.

                    1. I strongly recommend two homemade doughs:

                      The dough for pizza from Roberto Donna in "In Julia's Kitchen with Master Chefs". I make enough for eight pizzas and freeze what i don't use.

                      Most especially, a dough for pizza from Lynne Rosetto Kasper's "The Italian Country Table". I double it and again freeze what I don't use. The good thing about this one is that if you're pressed for time it need not have a long rise; a rest, then form and bake is just fine.

                      2 Replies
                      1. re: jmckee

                        Can you share the Roberto Donna's recipe; no luck finding it online except his video with Julia Child. His pizzas look amazing! Thanks :)

                        1. re: naokoshin

                          It's in "In Julia's Kitchen With Master Chefs". I don't think its available online.