Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Aug 10, 2009 02:13 PM

Softserve ice cream closer than Dairy Joy?

I'm asking for a friend who NEEDS a soft-serve ice cream cone with jimmies. Of course I know of Dairy Joy in Weston, but is there anything great and closer?

Any chance Toscanini has soft serve? They have fro-yo and sorbet, but soft serve?

Thanks for leads.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Two choices, in order of recommendation:

    Kell's Kreme on Revere Beach Parkway, a block or so north of Kelly's. The single best soft-serve cone I have ever had.

    Celebrity in Watertown. Closer still, and nearly as good.

    3 Replies
    1. re: BarmyFotheringayPhipps

      I was hoping you'd chime in here Barmy -- I recall you having strong opinions about the topic. :-)

        1. re: BarmyFotheringayPhipps

          Kell's Kreme hands down. My 2nd and 3rd and 4th favs(in no particular order) are the ice cream/florist place on rt 16 in Everett and the soft serve place on Adams St in East Milton on the way to Quincy across from Montillios and Ron's in Hyde Park..

        2. yumyum, Carvel on Eastern Ave. in Malden has pretty creamy soft serve, so far the creamiest I've found. The vanilla at Louie's on Broadway in Somerville is also quite good. I didn't try the chocolate since the machine was broken.

          I find that both are richer (i.e. seem to have more actual butterfat) than Dairy Joy or Celebrity in Watertown (no fried clams, though). I'm assuming both have jimmies.

          Here's a post with lots of options, although not too many close to you.

          8 Replies
          1. re: bear

            There's an actual Carvel store around still?

            1. re: BarmyFotheringayPhipps

              Yup. The setting isn't exactly relaxing since it's right on busy Eastern Ave., but the ice cream is still pretty creamy and the vanilla has a pretty natural taste. The chocolate flavor is decent, although I'd like it a bit more chocolatey. We like Celebrity, but find Carvel a bit richer.

              Here's link to the three Mass. stores:


              Meanwhile, I have to get to Kell's Kreme. My husband in particular is a real soft serve fan, and it sounds really good.

            2. re: bear

              Do they still have Fudgy the Whale??

              1. re: Gabatta

                Sorry, forgot to check! Next time...

                1. re: bear

                  never mind Fudgie the Whale, I want to know if they still have Cookie-Puss!

                  1. re: Ralphie_in_Boston

                    Cookie Puss and Fudgie, aaaah just rotate the ice cream mold 180 degrees and they are in fact the same.

                    This place in Salem does a pretty good frozen custard:


                    I haven't tried it, but what about this place in Arlington:

                  1. re: rebeccacceber

                    Love it! Those commericials bring back memories.

              2. there is also dairy maid on broadway in everett

                1. Truly Yogurt in wellesley is delicious - i literally go there everynight! so good!

                  1. I second Kell's Kreme, although it's been a few years. I also recall enjoying a huge cone at a place on rte 16 in Everett, forget the name.

                    3 Replies
                    1. re: Kip McSkipster

                      I have tried Louie's soft serve in the past which was fine but never really latched onto it, but not this year. Spadafora on Highland in Malden (hey Yum Yum, combine it with a trip to Fuloon, also have a really cheap banana split with hard or ss ice cream) and Celebrity (pricier/smaller, but better for a SS cone with a dip) have been my standbys this year. My suggestion, though, would be for YumYum to give Alexander's on Main St in Medford a try where I have only had the hard ice cream and let us know. As far as Louie's grape nut custard, as far as I know its Richardson's... which you can get it at a lot of places nearby, Alexander's, CB Scoops in Medford, Jay's in Malden, Dairy King in Everett, Spadafora... There also is one more ice cream place in Medford that I haven't found open ever but mostly in the offseason. I think the Chilly Cow has some, but not all Richardson's flavors. Alexander's, Jay's, New Deal Fruit have the Richardson's 1/2 gallons.

                      1. re: Kip McSkipster

                        I like Kell's Kreme, but most people I know don't. It's definitely convenient to Boston, though.