Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Aug 10, 2009 09:36 AM

I scream you scream....

We're always trying to find a good ice cream spot. My husband and I were so dispointed when we went all the way to cambridge (!) :) to try Christina's Ice Cream. The service was rude, the ice cream forgettable. I had chocolate and all I could taste was the fat. Barely any flavor at all. My husband got the fresh mint (which was pretty good) and a scoop of dark chocolate (okay). Not sure why people like this place...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I have a deep love for the burnt sugar ice cream at Toscanini's, practically next door to Christina's. Also, I haven't been for quite a while, but I'm a big fan of Herrell's in Harvard Square. Interesting flavors, cool mix ins, and they used have (hope they still do) really fabulous chocolate whipped cream.

    2 Replies
    1. re: Northshoregirl

      I also love the burnt sugar ice crema at Toscanini's (imho a much better ice cream place than Christina's). I tried the burnt sugar ice cream at a Christina's stand at the Farmer's Market at Kendall last week and I thought it was only OK. The ice cream quality was fine, but the flavor was mild, missing the deep rich burnt sugar flavor that I find in the Tosci's version.

      1. re: jgleeche

        I'm pretty sure Tosci's has burnt Caramel which gives it a more intense flavor. The burnt caramel and mexican chocolate flavors, together, is one of the best combos ever.

    2. Head a little north to White Farm in Ispwich, I can't wait for Pumpkin ice cream there. Also, Benson's in Boxford for some truly awesome seasonal native fruit flavor ice creams ot frozen yogurt.

      6 Replies
      1. re: treb

        Totally agree with the White Farms recommendation. I also really like Richardson's ice cream.

        1. re: owen_meany

          Richardson's rocks, lots of places on the N. Shore carry it, and so does the Somerville Theater.

          1. re: StriperGuy

            True but I have found that it really is worth the effort to go to either Middleton or Reading to get it from an actual Richardson's outlet... at least for one of my favorite flavors, Toll House Cookie. Perhaps those locations have higher turnover, or store it better, but when I've gotten that flavor at those locations, the cookie still had a bit of crunch, whereas when I've gotten it in other ice cream stores that offer Richardson's, it's all mushy.

            1. re: Chris VR

              My favorites are their Maple Walnut (absolute best I've ever had) or any of the blackberry or raspberry based flavors.

              1. re: Chris VR

                I agree with this. We actually live a stone's throw from the Reading location so we don't have to venture far but I also think that the Middleton ice cream surpasses the Reading outlet by a smidge, too. AND I can only get my favorite, German Chocolate Cake, at Middleton.

          2. re: treb

            Pumpkin ice cream at White Farms... like my favorite thing in the world! In a hot fudge good. Can't wait for fall.

          3. As i am completely addicted to Christina's extraordinary Kulfi (cardamom) ice cream, you may find my recs invalid. (Definitely agree about the staff's rude ' could care less' attitude.)
            JPLicks, in my book, has excellent ice cream . However, I would counsel you that with all ice cream places giving you free tastes of anything you'd like, you really have nothing to complain about. . Take responsibility for your own happiness.Wherever you go, be confident; don't let them intimidate you; request samples until you find one you like.

            3 Replies
            1. re: opinionatedchef

              ...unless there are people waiting in line behind you.

              1. re: opinionatedchef

                Have you had the Kulfi at Rancatore's? I have and it's my fav. right now. I'm wondering how it campares to Christina's/

                1. re: catsmeow

                  that's interesting to hear. i have not tried r's kulfi; had no idea they had it , and will try it now. however, r's is a much less heavy product that Ch's so I'm guessing that means less butterfat.

              2. I hadn't been to Toscanini's Central Square for quite a while and stopped in last night (following lackluster dinner and oversweet cocktails at Cuchi Cuchi - won't be back there for a while at least...) for dessert - and wow - they are really back at the top of their game IMHO - the sugar plum sherry and bourbon vienna finger flavors I had were spectacular, as was the standby nocciola and new to me orange butter flake and buttermilk flavors my friends had - I love Herrells and Christina's as well, but Tosci's is my go to for now (the garlic flavor was interesting but needs some kind of pairing to work for me).

                1 Reply
                1. re: rlh

                  rlh, plse do tell us about Orange Butter flake. what IS it?? thanks.

                2. Oreo at Meletharb's, yum! I also love Cravings in Wakefield, Schoolhouse in Burlington, Carter's in Haverhill, Ron's in Dedham, Kimball Farms in Carlisle....Massachusetts has more good ice cream per square foot than any other place in the WORLD!

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: jillso

                    Seriously, statistically speaking MA supposedly has the highest per capita ice cream consumption.