HOME > Chowhound > Washington DC & Baltimore >

Vintage 51 coming to South Riding

Bob W Jul 29, 2009 05:53 AM

This is a spin-off of Vintage 50 in Leesburg, which I have long wanted to try and now won't have to since I live so close to where Vintage 51 will be.

So, what's the word on Vintage 50? They must be doing pretty well, but is the food any good?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Trip Klaus RE: Bob W Jul 29, 2009 01:11 PM

    When I visited I found the food no better than your average Applebees and their beer insipid.

    2 Replies
    1. re: Trip Klaus
      marleymom RE: Trip Klaus Jul 31, 2009 03:15 PM

      That's not been my experience there (though I can't speak for the beer)...
      We've been several times. It's not my top restaurant in Leesburg, but the last couple of times I've been have been good - definitely improved in the last year or so. I had a short rib dish last winter that was fabulous...it was homey, almost stew-like. Delicious and perfect for a winter meal.

      1. re: Trip Klaus
        Insidious Rex RE: Trip Klaus Aug 25, 2009 10:37 AM

        I would hardly call Bill Madden's stuff insipid. I like the Kolsch among others and he's won at least half a dozen medals for his brews. Cant wait for the Mad Fox to open. As for the food, I have eaten brunch there and it was pretty good.

      2. m
        mgoldid RE: Bob W Aug 24, 2009 05:30 PM

        I had one beer which was not drinkable and they gave me another one - can't recall the name. Wife had the dark beer - the Bells Porter, tasted like dunkle from Germany. She gives it 10 thumbs up! We were having our Friday after work drink and tried the chicken wings - they were quite good. Not your normal bar wings, much better.

        We are returning in 2 weeks for dinner - the menu looks quite good. There is a cheese fondue appetizer, steak frites, pot roast and a berry cobbler with gelato plus some other yummies. They are going to have 24 gelato flavors soon.

        1. j
          jendrew99 RE: Bob W Aug 28, 2009 12:20 PM

          I agree with the previous poster about the food... average at best. The beer, however, is fab.

          1. d
            dryren RE: Bob W Sep 2, 2009 08:16 AM

            I've been to Vintage 51 twice now. Each time the beer has been off the chart great! I had the pork tenderloin the 1st time and it was good. They're definitely more "european" on the portion sizes, but I do like the fact that the produce is all local. For me that makes up for the portion size and price. The Muscles appetizer is amazing. I got it as a meal my 2nd time there. At only $9, I felt it was a good deal. Overall, I'm very pleased with the joint and will definitely be going back once they have their full menu available.

            1. p
              PrincessWinnie RE: Bob W Sep 3, 2009 05:11 AM

              We actually just went last night (9/2/09). Had a terrific meal and the beer was great. The cheese fondue app is ADDICTIVE, we actually told the waiter we think they should make it a larger portion. I had the trout with mustard greens which was done very well and hubby had the pork tenderloin which he practically licked clean. Other diners had the crabmeat cheesecake and seafood stew which were also excellent. Service was terrific, we had a very friendly and helpful waiter. I definitely hope this place hangs in there and continues to improve, we REALLY need another option besides Ruby Tuesday for general continental cuisine here in South Riding.

              1. bnafff RE: Bob W Jan 14, 2010 06:19 AM

                The food at this place is TERRIBLE. Just no thought or heart is put into it.
                The kitchen REALLY needs to teach their cooks how to execute a dish.
                Deep fried gnocchi swimming in a grainy cream sauce does not equate gratin. They need to scale down their menu to pub food with a local and sustainable feel. They obviously do not have the talent or the means to execute a medium sized semi-gourmet menu.
                I've been here twice and Ive had poor service each time.
                Go for the beer.
                Do not order the food.
                It's funny, the executive chef and chef de cuisine's names are printed on the door. I would be embarassed to have my name put on that menu/restaurant.

                1. ktmoomau RE: Bob W Jan 14, 2010 07:42 AM

                  Just thought I would add my two cents. We went to Vintage 50 instead of the Leesburg Wine Kitchen the night of the fire at the Chinese Restaurant next door.

                  While I wasn't crazy about the bread or the spread options, the amuse bouche was tasty. I had the roasted chicken which I know it is pretty hard to make bad roasted chicken, but it was very good and I liked all the accompaniments. I liked that each entree came with a salad, and a choice of salad at that. Made the price much more reasonable.

                  I forget what we all had for dessert, but we were all happy. Went with another couple and no one disliked their meal. I am sure it wasn't the wine kitchen, but it was certainly much much better than applebees, and while perhaps not as refined as some other restaurants I thought they had good flavor pairings with fresh ingredients and a nice selection. The beer was very good, and they had a decent selection of wine and spirits for a brewery.

                  Show Hidden Posts