HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >

O'Barone in Red Hook

j
jinx Jul 22, 2009 02:34 PM

Has anyone tried this new place O'Barone, which is in the old 360 spot in Red Hook? (360 Van Brundt.)

http://gothamist.com/2009/07/14/new_r...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Steve R RE: jinx Jul 23, 2009 07:28 AM

    Yes, my wife and I went last week. A very friendly place with an owner out to please. Pastas imported from Italy, not homemade. Small menu. Very reasonable prices. Moderate sized portions. Simple, neighborhood fare.

    All in all, we'll let it go for awhile and see how it develops before we go back. We liked the food well enough but it isnt a destination place at all (at least at this point). If I lived in the immediate neighborhood, I'd probably drop by every couple of weeks for a nice dinner, well prepared. If it were on Smith St., it would probably be ignored. But, it seems to be the type of place that might just get its bearings and become something. We'll see.

    2 Replies
    1. re: Steve R
      lambretta76 RE: Steve R Jul 23, 2009 08:09 AM

      My wife and I, too, went last week, and were pleased. Maybe not a destination in the way that 360 once was, but the cooking is solid, the salads extremely large and filling, and the service laid back but friendly.

      As for the pasta, I tried the lasagna and would be surprised if it wasn't fresh pasta. That lasagna, by the way, is a sauceless lasagna made with red and yellow bell peppers - if you like peppers, it's quite good. (I like them.)

      They're aiming to please, and are priced reasonably. Starters were mostly $8 to $9, save for a meat and cheese plate which I think was $14. Entrees seemed to be in the $12-$15 range.

      It's a very solid neighborhood joint; for those looking for a light dinner I'd suggest a glass of wine and one of their grain salads, which are filling and tasty.

      1. re: lambretta76
        j
        jinx RE: lambretta76 Jul 23, 2009 08:22 AM

        thanks, seems worth checking out as we are always looking for a place to have a reasonably priced, less expensive casual meal. We may go tomorrow night, I'll report back.

    2. j
      jinx RE: jinx Jul 25, 2009 07:58 PM

      So we did go on Friday night. I concur with the others--a really nice neighborhood place, unassuming, and very reasonably priced. The chef/owner came over and sat with us for awhile (it was empty when we arrived at around 7) and he was very welcoming and seemed like a genuinely nice guy. Talked about his home town (Bergamo) and his take on Italian food, interesting guy. There were several specials in addition to the regular menu; everything we had was quite good--simple, but well prepared and tasty. Because the chef's heritage is both Italian and Austrian, there were some Austrian dishes--I had a special of pork schnitzel with roast potatoes, cabbage slaw (very good and I usually don't care much for the Austrian-style slaw). My husband had a pasta with a sausage ragu which was good. For starters we had tommino cheese and pancetta over grilled radicchio and a huge salad of lentils, apples, and grilled asparagus.

      Our only "complaint" was that the wine list, while well-chosen, had no bottles (of red anyway--didn't look at whites) under $30. When entrees are $12-$16 tops, it would be nice to have a few wines available in the $25 dollar range (and this is certainly possible with Italian wines.) We did order a $30 bottle of Nero d'Avola which was delicious.

      hope this place succeeds--we'll definitely go back. It was filling up when we left at 8:30.

      1. j
        jinx RE: jinx Sep 18, 2009 10:27 AM

        wondering if anyone has been here recently, curious if they've expanded/changed the menu at all. Was thinking of going tonight.

        1. l
          lazylghtng RE: jinx Apr 22, 2010 09:26 AM

          No action on this place for a while now -- any recent reports?

          5 Replies
          1. re: lazylghtng
            Bob Martinez RE: lazylghtng Apr 22, 2010 01:59 PM

            I recently passed by at around 9:30 on a Friday evening. The place was pretty busy. I'm sorry I can't comment about the food but the fact that they're still doing good business in an out of the way neighborhood is a good sign.

            1. re: Bob Martinez
              l
              lazylghtng RE: Bob Martinez Apr 23, 2010 06:28 AM

              Thanks, Bob. We ended up going last night and it was just great! Very sweet staff, very homespun and authentic vibe -- no glitz, no pretense, but also not devoid of creature comforts like ambience and proper lighting, etc. And the food is clearly cooked with love. We had two excellent starter salads - farro with greens, mushrooms, chickpeas, and grana padano; and baby spinach with beets, potatoes, green beans, and ricotta salata. For mains, we had two excellent pastas - fantastic ravioli with asparagus sauce (kind of nutty like a pesto); and a special of homemade tagliatelle with calamari and pancetta in a spicy tomato sauce that was out of this world. Pasta were 12-14$ and salads were $8 each. One of the better and more enjoyable meals I've had in a while. I hope they make it! It was less than half-full last night btw. 6:45 - 8:15. I like the Austrian-influenced curveballs -- they were running a special of goulash, alongside the regular menu offerings of pork schnitzel and also a nice-looking spaetzle dish. We are def returning.

              -----
              O'Barone
              360 Van Brunt Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231

              1. re: lazylghtng
                b
                boccalupo RE: lazylghtng Apr 23, 2010 08:29 AM

                I've only been once. Last September. I thought the food was quite good, but thought the wine prices were way too high (I think the lowest price wine was $32) in view of the ambience and neighoborhood. Have they added any less expensive selections since then?

                Noodle Pudding has a bottle of drinkable red at $14 and many excellent selections under $30.

                If Trader Joe's can sell high quality wine for under $6 a bottle retail, why can't other restaurants offer us a bottle or two in the $15 $20 range. That would still allow a nice markup for the resto.

                -----
                Noodle Pudding
                38 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

                1. re: boccalupo
                  Bob Martinez RE: boccalupo Apr 23, 2010 09:49 AM

                  "thought the food was quite good, but thought the wine prices were way too high..."

                  That's where O'Barone is choosing to make it's profits. The entrees average under $13. If they bumped them up to $16 and dropped their wine prices the effect would be the same. Either way, it's still a cheap night out.

              2. re: Bob Martinez
                Puppimus RE: Bob Martinez Apr 24, 2010 09:18 AM

                I went last night for the first time. DELICIOUS. Had the calamari and baby arugula app and the faggotini pasta, which are little purses of gorgonzola (mixed with something milder--it definitely was not a lump of pure gorgonzola) in a walnut sauce with sweet pear cubes. It was so rich and unique. My bf had the spaetzle with bacon and cheese sauce, and he was very pleased as well. Total bill for 1 app and 2 pastas was $40.
                It was very crowded last night and we were wedged between two loud parties of 10, so while I will definitely be back, I'll try to make it weeknight instead! I wanted to try the chocolate sausage dessert, but just couldn't bear staying there any longer. I'm really glad they're doing well, though. If you're going on a Friday or Saturday, I suggest reservations.

            2. g
              gfood RE: jinx Apr 23, 2010 10:56 AM

              I've been twice, and I had a great time on both occasions. The atmosphere is casual, and the service is eclectic: we had the same waiter twice. On the last visit we arrived for an early dinner, and the waiter just sat down with us to take our order: he was very entertaining.

              The food is great, we've had the brasaeola carpaccio, the tuna carpaccio for starters, and the pappardelle and pork schnitzel on the visits. All the ingredients were fresh, and we really enjoyed both meals.

              The dinner prices are reasonable, and I didn't find the wine exceptionally overpriced compared to other restaurants.

              Anyway, I consider Al Di La the best Italian in Bklyn, and I would put this a notch below; but it is still makes for an excellent meal and a fun evening. Mass transit is tough to get there, but drving is easy, and parking is easy as well.

              -----
              Al Di La
              248 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

              1. l
                lazylghtng RE: jinx May 1, 2010 08:30 AM

                Well, we returned last night for a 2nd visit. My oh my, how much things can change in a week. In short, we had a terrible experience. The lentil salad (as was the case last week with the beets/potato, and also the faro salad) was excellent - bright and clean. But the grilled scamorza with pancetta and radicchio was horrendous -- terribly plated, and undressed. For mains, the bread gnocchi with squash tasted like Thansgiving stuffing -- really stock-y and herb-y upon first bite, then boring thereafter. It would be a fun side with a meat entree, but falls flat on its own. Its beige color and 5" length were also wholly unappetizing. We tried some of the Austrian dishes tonight as well -- the pork schnitzel and the spaetzle. The pork was perfectly fried, but tough. It could have used less time cooking or better yet the juicy benefit of brining. Made me wish it were veal from the first bite. The spaetzle with pancetta and cheese was gummy and dry -- basically, a bad Austrian mac & cheese. We didn't try the specials, but were let down that out of the two specials one was the same as last week -- goulash, a curious choice on such a warm spring night. The other was tagliatelle with mushrooms -- not very special.

                Last week, the Italian waiter -- who was sweet and charming -- was very attentive and welcoming. He also played Italian music on the stereo which befit the surroundings. The lone server last night was a different guy, and pretty much on another planet all evening. He colored the ambience with the stereo tuned to classic rock from --wait for it -- a radio station. Not very atmospheric and I am a lover of classic rock, just not in italian restaurants unless it is Babbo! Out of the 4 red wines by the glass, they were out of the best which is a supertuscan and weren't substituting anything comparable. We were then informed that he hadn't chilled the rose or prosecco which were still sitting in their delivery boxes by the bar so those were out, too. This on a Friday. When he brought olive oil with the bread, he forgot to put it on the table and walked away with it. When he came back, we asked for the oil and he realized his mistake, saying "classic" to us before returning to pour the oil into the bowl as well as dripping it onto my mother-in-law's menu (he was oblivious). He also told us that they were out of fagotini despite it being only 6:30 at night. Lame (although not his fault). When he brought the apps, he asked who got what despite his having personally taken our order and our party being only two couples and a toddler. Even though there were only a handful of tables occupied in an already small setting, he was not very conscious of his guests and it was challenging to get his attention. IHe just didn't seem to be trying very hard and was very aloof. Not a jerk, just not altogether there nor charming in that manner. In sum, the food was disappointing, but the service and ambience were even more inexplicable.

                1. w
                  Westminstress RE: jinx May 1, 2010 01:07 PM

                  We tried this place about a week ago. For three people, we shared two appetizers (farro salad and grilled calamari salad) and two pastas (asparagus ravioli and spaetzle). Everything was fine, no real standouts. Actually, we did enjoy the salads. I thought the pastas were a bit heavy though. Even the asparagus pasta was mostly cheese. They have no vegetables on the menu, and when we asked if they could make us some (I'm pregnant so I try to eat a lot of veggies) they only had salad. We also had dessert, apple strudel with mixed berry sauce (this was pretty good). The service was horrible. There was only one waiter for the entire restaurant, and no busboys. I think it must have been the same waiter that lazylghting had, because he was horrible. Our meal took more than two hours because we spent so much time waiting between courses.

                  Show Hidden Posts