Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Jul 22, 2009 11:23 AM

"No Reservations" Sichuan Cuisine

To all those familiar with "No Reservations,"

In this past weeks episode, Anthony Bourdain spent time in Melbourne, Australia. One of the standout restaurants was a Sichuan establishment. If anyone knows of any authentic Sichuan restaurants in the Manhattan area, I would very much appreciate you feedback.

Many thanks,

CM Robbins II

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
    1. re: kathryn

      definitely second wu liang ye!

      1. re: kathryn

        I want to emphasize that only the 39th St. location of Szechuan Gourmet is very good.

          1. re: Pan

            The one by Columbus Circle has really disappointed me the past three or four visits, even when I beg them for 'extra spicy'. But it's not just that, it's almost like they lost a whole level of complexity in the sauces and can't get it back. I was starting to wonder if it is just the lunchtime kitchen staff that has slipped, or the whole place in general.

            1. re: TongoRad

              Based on their attitude and cooking the first time we went there, we will never return. The food at the 39th St restaurant is brilliant.

        1. Flushing, Queens is the #1 go-to place for Chinese food in NYC. I would post your question on the outer boroughs board.

          6 Replies
          1. re: Ann900

            I must agree. I've eaten some pretty good Sichuan food in Manhattan (particularly at Grand Sichuan St. Marks) but if you want the REALLY excellent stuff, you really have to go to Flushing. Little Pepper and Chengdu Heaven (or Chengdu Sky House or however you translate it) in Flushing blow the Manhattan choices (or the ones I've tried anyway) out of the water, and the food really tastes like it does in Sichuan Province. But not much English is spoken.

            1. re: Ike

              For me the ultimate Sichuan place in Flushing is Spicy and Tasty.

              1. re: Ann900

                I've not explored the menu enough at S&T but it seems really tasty to me but not quite spicy enough. I may need to request it?

                My favorite in Manhattan is Szechuan Gourmet. GS St Marks is good but you have to order carefully. Whereas SG is amazing and up there with Chengdu Sky House aka Chengdu Tian Fu aka Chengfu Heaven in the Golden Shopping Mall.

                1. re: kathryn

                  My one visit to Szechuan Gourmet on 39th St. was slightly disappointing, because there wasn't any serious heat in any of the dishes, even the ones that were supposed to be spicy. Nor were they as flavorful as what I've eaten in Flushing. They weren't bad at all, but there wasn't much kick. But a Chinese friend was ordering and maybe she instructed them not to make it too spicy. I don't think she's as keen on Sichuan spice as I am. I'll have to go back and try it again.

                  1. re: Ike

                    Yeah.. give them another try. Based on my experience, their food can be quite hot and spicy so I think your friend probably asked them to go light on the heat. I actually know quite a few Chinese people who prefer to eat lighter, less spicy food for various reasons so it's not uncommon for them to order less spicy versions of Szechuan food.. even though they are Chinese.

                    1. re: Ike

                      In my experience, there was a slight decrease in consistency right after Bruni's review in the NYT, but a few months later, they were certainly back on track.

            2. For me, Szechuan Gourmet in Manhattan precludes a Flushing visit for Sichuanese. I think they have the largest and most extensive menu - including Pidan, the 1000 Year Old Egg with Green Chili appetizer which is wonderful. In Flushing, I prefer Little Pepper, Spicy and Tasty and Chengdu Heaven in that order. I've been disappointed by Chengdu Heaven the past couple of visits (Chef not in, bland Dan Dan Noodles.)

              9 Replies
              1. re: scoopG

                While some dishes are better at Wu Liang Ye (like tea smoked duck), Szechuan Gourmet is probably the best bet in Manhattan. I think I may also prefer the dan dan noodles and ma po dofu at Wu Liang Ye. There's a spicy whole fish at Szechuan Gourmet that's really amazing (it might be a 4-pepper dish). I don't think any of the Grand Sichuans compare to either of these. In Queens I prefer Little Pepper to Spicy & Tasty except for the amazing selection of cold dishes at S&T.


                1. re: Peter Cherches

                  Yep, it's the cold dishes I crave at S$T .

                  As for Kathryn's question of whether their food is spicy enough- is it spicy enough for you if it brings tears to the eyes of super spicy food fans?

                  1. re: Ann900

                    Maybe they toned it down for us because it was a mixed group (some Asian American, some not) and we ordered a mix of hot/cooked dishes?

                    SG brings tears to my eyes and clears my sinuses on a regular basis. Some of the food is so spicy, I can't even finish it.

                  2. re: Peter Cherches

                    I think the midtown WLY is the only good WLY. The best Dan Dan Noodles I've found so far are at Strange Taste in Chinatown.

                    1. re: scoopG

                      Strange Taste closed and now I'm lost.... I miss those guys... anyone know where they went? Where now for Dan dan & Zha zhang?

                      1. re: allisterk

                        I like the Dan Dan noodles at Szechuan Gourmet on 39th. Some folks here like the ones at Wu Liang Ye. I have also tried the Dan Dan noodles at Grand Sichuan on St. Marks.. not bad either... (I think my favorite is the one at Szechuan Gourmet.) You can check them out and see what's your favorite.

                        1. re: allisterk

                          Went by Strange Taste today, not realizing they'd closed, and a woman inside said they'd be opening tomorrow. So something's moving into the space, not sure yet what. I'll be stopping by soon to check it out and will report back.

                          1. re: Emmmily

                            Yeah, it had been closed since sometime in spring, then earlier this week I saw the gate was up and a woman and her kids were sitting at a table. But they seemed to be the new tenants and it was clear they weren't yet open for business. Never made it to Strange Taste so I don't know if these were the same folks.

                            1. re: squid kun

                              never got to try it either, but i walked by it a few days ago and i believe its another fujian place as thats what it was advertised as (literally said fuzhou food in chinese) and all the dishes looked like the typical fujian stuff

                  3. in you enjoyed that episode, you should also try to check out the No Res episode where he goes to Chengdu, Sichuan...

                    my fav in Manhattan is the GS branch at 9th Ave/24 St...i usually get guizhou spicy chicken, the prawn w/ chilies special, sliced fish and sour cabbage soup, and cold cucumbers in scallion sauce...

                    1. not sure about sichuan in manhattan, but try spicy and tasty in flushing, i had a great meal there and the spices they use were delicious