HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >

Bistro Jeanty, Girl and the Fig or Somewhere Else?

a
asb165 Jul 19, 2009 11:55 AM

Visiting hound from Philadelphia looking for a third dinner to fill out a short trip to Napa. We're eating at Bottega and Redd on our second and third nights, and are looking for a Sunday dinner spot.

Is there a consensus on which of these two French spots is superior? We're a 30 year old couple travelling out West for our 5th anniversary. Has the Sunday Supper at Press gotten positive reviews? Thanks for your help!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. CarrieWas218 RE: asb165 Jul 19, 2009 05:02 PM

    I think Press is horrifically over-priced for what they offer, although three courses for $55 *might* be okay, depending on what is being offered. To me, it is still basically a hunk-o-meat restaurant. Other highlights in the area are Ubuntu (my favorite), Terra, or Martini House.

    2 Replies
    1. re: CarrieWas218
      a
      adamshoe RE: CarrieWas218 Jul 19, 2009 05:50 PM

      I second Carrie on the Martini House. Have a drink at the very cool, speak-easy like bar downstairs; then go upstairs (or not) for dinner. Amazing spirits list; more like a Bible (or an Imbible, hee-hee). If they're serving mushroom soup-GET IT!! If not, the onion soup is deliciously over the top- more onions than soup. Haven't been to Terra, but hear only great things about it. adam

      1. re: CarrieWas218
        v
        vday RE: CarrieWas218 Jul 19, 2009 07:21 PM

        Haven't tried Ubuntu yet, but concur with Martini house. I haven't eaten at Terra recently, but last time I was there the food was excellent too. I think the vibe is a little more in keeping with your age category at Martini House. Terra seemed a little more formal to me.

      2. pastryqueen RE: asb165 Jul 19, 2009 08:18 PM

        second Carrie's suggestion for Ubuntu. . recently had dinner there and it was phenomenal. . .ate outside which I enjoyed more than eating in the main dining room. . .had a gnochetti that I won't soon forget. .. it was sensational. . the menu changes almost daily so it will most likely be different when you go. . but they offer the same items but in different "sets" so I would suggest the Carta Musica, the gnochetti, and this time I loved the set for the housemade fregola - which I did not love last time. The signature cauliflower "gratin' is always on the menu but it's not my favorite - but it is very well regarded. They changed their signature chick pea fries and now they are little bunches of chick peas fried in a pakora-like batter. . they are even better than the amazing chick pea fries. Desserts are amazing. .. again, my least favorite of the bunch is the signature "cheesecake" - it's good but the rest are better! I think missing this restaurant while being in Napa would be a shame.

        1. c
          cyberroo RE: asb165 Jul 20, 2009 12:31 PM

          I haven't been to Bistro Jeanty, but I don't think that Girl and the Fig is necessarily worth the drive over the hill to Sonoma, unless it's part of a larger part of a visit to the town. It's a good little restaurant, but nothing exceptional. If you do decide on it, request patio seating - the dining rooms are crowded and loud, but the back patio is lovely.

          But if it were me, I'd go to Ubuntu or Ad Hoc. I find it difficult to talk about either of these without sounding like a teenage fangirl, but suffice it to say that Ubuntu is genuinely remarkable and it's a lovely space. Ad Hoc is my next favorite, but gets occasional mixed reviews - mostly from people who didn't like the menu on the night they went, which is a risk.

          1 Reply
          1. re: cyberroo
            k
            KathyM RE: cyberroo Jul 20, 2009 06:39 PM

            Ditto on Girl and the Fig, very underwhelming food but the patio area is nice for a snack, perhaps the fries. But don't have a full meal there.

          2. g
            garyp02 RE: asb165 Jul 20, 2009 03:39 PM

            I agree with Carrie Martini House in St Helena is amazing. Honestly I'd skip Bottega it is very ordinary. Go across the street to Bouchon. It is truly excellent.

            Show Hidden Posts