HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Discussion

Lobsters - boiled vs. steamed

Which is the better method for preparing?

Probably the best lobster I've had is at The Lobster Pound in Ogunquit, ME, where they keep the lobsters in an enormous tank of ocean water. And then, I believe, they boil them in the ocean water.

Short of having ocean water at one's disposal, is it better to steam or to boil?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Steamed for sure. In salty water. No reason not to use sea salt and get as close to Ogunquit ocean water as you can. Use enough liquid, even if it partly covers the lobster, to retain for use as broth for dipping at the table.

    9 Replies
    1. re: BernalKC

      Short of having ocean water at one's disposal, is it better to steam or to boil?........lobstaman

      Steamed for sure. In salty water........BernalCK
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

      Here in lies the confusion for most., Steamed and boiled is used interchangeably for most minds. I am by no expert, but I find steaming above the waterline results in less shrinkage and more apt to be less tough from over cooking....however, I find boiling lobsters in salted water or ocean water to have more sea/ocean taste...I guess it's the added salt.

      Ultimately, if cooked properly...or should I say if not overcooked, either way is fine for me. I can't say I have ever dipped any lobster in broth or cooking liquid, but I will say I have dipped always in drawn butter.

      1. re: fourunder

        Without doubt this will ignite a furor but, I have cookbooks from the 1930's--and a few articles from Gourmet from shortly afterward (when it wass finally started) that insist on sea water OR water with a little iodine in it to replicate sea water. then, it is insisted, the lobsters must be started in cold water and the heat brought up slowly to a boil. Anticipating howls, these guys insisted that lobsters cannot feel and are just sent off to sleep. As an alternative, one author just says sever the spinal cord and that's that. The argument is that plunging a lobster--or crawfish, for that matter---into boiling water toughens it.

        1. re: hazelhurst

          I once put lobsters in a pot that was not boiling yet, and from the wild splashing I can assure you they felt something.

          1. re: coll

            ...started in cold water and heat brought up slowly to boil...... is far different than.......

            ...pot that was not boiling yet.....

            1. re: fourunder

              Let's just say I like to get it over with quickly now. I just say "I'm sorry" as I put them in head first.

              1. re: coll

                I just say "I'm sorry" as I put them in head first.

                ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

                I've been known to say something similar.......

                "I'm sorry Mary Tyler Moore"

                1. re: fourunder

                  I actually say "I'm sorry but you have to die". I don't know why, but I do it when I kill bugs too. Like me being sorry makes up for everything.

            2. re: coll

              Well, I've heard of people who put bricks on top of the lid and such like...I've never done it myself, just reporting what learned cooks said a long time ago. I imagine a lobster might thrash anyway in a confined space. maybe there is a scientific-type out there.

              1. re: coll

                Worse - I once watched a lobsterman snap the tails and then claws off live lobsters before putting them in the pot.

        2. My experience is that boiling in salted water gives a better texture than steaming.

          1. IMO, it doesn't make a bit of difference whether you steam them or boil them, the trick is not to over-cook or under-cook them. "Salt" is sodium chloride; except for iodized salt there is no real difference in salt. It all comes (or came) from the ocean. Either in recent history or in ancient history. There is a difference in the size of the granules (table salt, kosher salt, pickling salt) and some, admittedly, do contain trace minerals but you'll be wasting your money if you spend extra bucks on a special salt. Ocean water's hint of unusual flavor comes from sea weed and minerals in the water, not the salt.
            Be sure you have enough boiling water in your tall pot to fully submerge the lobster.
            Salt the water heavily to about 3% - 3.5% by weight (unless you're using sea water) and bring to a full boil.
            Select a live, active lobster rather than a docile inactive critter.
            It should be heavy for its size
            Use tongs to pick it up and place it (don't drop it) into the water head first and hold it down to prevent it from flapping its tail and splashing boiling water onto you or others.
            When it becomes inactive, allow it to remain at full boil for 5 - 15 minute, depending on size, weight and shell thickness, until it is completely cooked.
            You'll know it's done when you can't flex the tail easily; the tail will be rather stiff and inflexible. If you can easily flex the tail, the lobster is not done.
            There is no set time for cooking a lobster. Their shells are not the same thickness and they differ in weight and muscle mass. After you gain some experience cooking them you'll develop a sense of when a certain shell characteristic/size/weight lobster is done to your liking.

            1 Reply
            1. re: todao

              A friend who used to own a seafood shop told me that when you see the white stuff floating out of the shell, it's done. Take it out right then.

            2. According to the Main Lobster Council....steaming vs. boiling......

              Benefits of Steaming
              In contrast, steaming is more gentle, yielding slightly more tender meat. It preserves a little more flavor and it’s more forgiving on the timing front. It’s harder to overcook a steamed lobster.

              Benefits of Boiling
              Boiling and steaming are the methods of choice when you want to serve diners a whole lobster. Boiling is a little quicker and easier to time precisely, and the meat comes out of the shell more readily than when steamed. For recipes that call for fully cooked and picked lobster meat boiling is the best approach

              http://www.lobsterfrommaine.com/steam...

              1. Ok, don't kill me. Years and years ago, my dad talked to some lobster man in Maine and he told him the "secret" to cooking lobsters - the microwave. Of course my dad tried it and honestly, it was fantastic. Even now my dad still cooks his lobsters like this; put the lobster in an ovenproof dish, cover with plastic wrap, high 7 minutes. It steams the lobsters from the inside out. Sacrilege, I know, but it really is good.

                4 Replies
                1. re: krisrishere

                  I seem to recall a scene from the movie Gremlins......only the sucker exploded...

                  ;)

                  1. re: krisrishere

                    It makes sense because you can "steam" a whole fish or fillets in the microwave.

                    1. re: krisrishere

                      Any time someone uses the microwave at work to warm up a serving of fish for 30 seconds the whole place reeks of fish. I'd worry about smell _ among other things _ if I tried to microwave a lobster.

                      1. re: NYCkaren

                        It honestly doesn't smell any different than if you were steaming them on the stove top. Plus, that smell is amazing to me :)

                    2. The Ogunquit lobster pound is boiling in salt water however a pound as busy as they are is boiling about a jillion bugs a day so the water becomes a lot more like lobster stock or an intense court-bouillon.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: Fritter

                        I wonder if they use that lobbie water...

                      2. Dont forget to dip that scrumptuos lobster meat in CLARIFIED BUTTER. Hate to see people invest in a lobster and then dip it in stick butter.

                        6 Replies
                        1. re: Butterguy

                          stick butter works great for me.....I'm just glad to be eating lobster

                          1. re: sdv231

                            No doubt just having lobster is a treat, but if you get the chance to dip it in Clarified do it, really emphasizes the flavors of the lobster. Clarified is typically what you will get at a high end restaurant that is serving lobster.

                            1. re: Butterguy

                              Clarified is just melted stick butter with the solids removed.

                              1. re: Fritter

                                Clarified butter=milk solids AND moisture removed.

                                1. re: Butterguy

                                  If you removed the "moisture" you would have nothing left. I assume that you meant to say ;
                                  Clarified butter= milk solids and water removed.
                                  In which case I would agree. It's still nothing more than melted stick butter which has been clarified. Other than aesthetics I'm not sure I see the difference in this application.

                                  1. re: Fritter

                                    The difference between stick butter melted and clarified melted. Clarified is essentially a concentrated butter flavor or a pure fat that will enhance all the other flavors that come in contact with it whether dipped, saute', or baked.
                                    The water/moisture and milk solids dull the butter flavor of regular stick butter.

                        2. I put them in a pot with a few inches of boiling water head first. Put the lid on and cook.

                          1 Reply
                          1. re: cassoulady

                            I always snip off the rubber bands just before the plunge. Am I being smart or silly?