HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >

raw vidalia onion in olive oil..... is it safe to eat?

alkapal Jun 18, 2009 09:30 PM

i've enjoyed the vidalia in good extra virgin olive oil with lemon juice and salt suggested by terkalin. it's good on lots of dishes.

i used it for a couple of days, and then left it out of the fridge for a day or so (in a closed tupperware). i've put it back in the fridge, but i'm a little concerned whether it is safe to eat. (i made the onion condiment probably two weeks ago).

here's my question: do you think the onion has the same issues as raw garlic, i.e., not being safe (over time) in an anaerobic environment? if so, i'll throw it out. ;-((.

ps, i know it's "just an onion in olive oil," but why waste it if it's ok?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. c
    cimui RE: alkapal Jun 18, 2009 10:02 PM

    I haven't seen the recipe you're talking about, but based on stuff I've read in cooking magazines, the presence of a good amount of acid (lemon juice) would make garlic safe. Onions carry the same risk of botulism as garlic.

    If you're really concerned, maybe just throw the condiment into a stew or stirfry and cook the heck out of it.

    3 Replies
    1. re: cimui
      chococat RE: cimui Jun 19, 2009 12:43 PM

      It's not the live clostridium botulinum that causes the problem in botulism, it's the toxin that is produced by the bacteria that causes problems. The toxin is NOT destroyed by heat and remains even after the bacteria are all dead.

      1. re: chococat
        cimui RE: chococat Jun 19, 2009 03:56 PM

        Aha, thanks very much for the info, chococat!

        Do you, or anyone else, have any idea how much acid you need to make the garlic or onion / olive oil infusion safe for later consumption? I know that vinaigrettes with garlic, onion, olive oil and vinegar are generally considered safe.

        1. re: cimui
          maria lorraine RE: cimui Jun 19, 2009 08:54 PM

          Pierce the garlic clove several times with a knife and boil the cloves in vinegar is the trick I learned from Michele Anna Jordan, the author of a book on infused vinegars.

          The toxin dies at 140 degrees F...IIRC...but check to make sure.

    2. maria lorraine RE: alkapal Jun 19, 2009 03:09 AM

      Hiya, alkapal,

      I'd discard it. It's a bit old at this point anyway, and besides, after I first read your post,
      I thought, "Uh-oh, chances are it's not safe."

      Don't take the risk -- get rid of it, and make yourself a snappy new batch.

      1. g
        gordeaux RE: alkapal Jun 19, 2009 04:38 AM

        it's a bulb. I'm pretty sure the reason that garlic is a risk is because it's a bulb that grows underground.
        As you put it, "it's just an onion in oo"
        Trust me, it's NOT worth the risk.

        1. alkapal RE: alkapal Jun 19, 2009 06:37 AM

          thank you cimui, maria, and gordeaux. i appreciate your responses and value your opinions.

          ta-ta vi-da-li-a! ;-).

          1. nomadchowwoman RE: alkapal Jun 19, 2009 12:34 PM

            OK, this post has gotten me thinking. I routinely plunk a crushed garlic clove or two into 1/4 cup or so of olive oil and after a few hours on the counter, strain out the garlic and mix the garlicky oil into another cup or so of olive oil. Then I refrigerate, using the oil in marinades, to make aioli, and to brush on to bread, meat, or fish before grilling. It usually sits in the fridge a couple of weeks before I use it up. Is this risky?

            4 Replies
            1. re: nomadchowwoman
              beachmouse RE: nomadchowwoman Jun 19, 2009 12:38 PM

              Here's some info about infused olive oils and the botulism concern:


              1. re: beachmouse
                nomadchowwoman RE: beachmouse Jun 19, 2009 01:38 PM

                Thank you; that was very helpful. I had no idea!

                1. re: beachmouse
                  scott123 RE: beachmouse Dec 5, 2009 11:17 PM

                  These types of sites are very helpful, but I really wish they'd talk more about clostridium botulinum and salt. Low pH/acidic environments are know to be hostile, but so are salty environments. 10% salt is supposed to be very hostile, and, from what I'm reading, most soy sauce is in the 20% realm. I make an extremely garlic-y teriyaki that I store for weeks in the fridge. I do hit the 185 deg. F/1 minute mark when I use it, but it would still be nice to know where I'd be at spore wise without cooking it.

                  I also wouldn't mind some data on clostridium botulinum and sugar. I'm sure if you add enough sugar to garlic to drastically reduce water activity, botulism ceases to become a concern.

                  P.S. Just noticed the date on this thread. Sorry for the thread bump. I need to get to bed.

                  1. re: scott123
                    alkapal RE: scott123 Dec 6, 2009 03:00 AM

                    scott, your input is always welcome. plus, the information on these threads is good for time immemorial (or something like that).

              2. c
                Crispy skin RE: alkapal Jun 19, 2009 07:28 PM

                Wack it down and let us know how it goes.

                Show Hidden Posts