Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >
Jun 15, 2009 05:50 PM

Help! Where To Get The Best Cake?

I'd really love some help deciding on where to get a birthday cake. I think there may be some boards on this already but I was hoping for the most up to date opinions! I am looking for a place where they can customize in terms of decorating, I don't need a sculpted cake as it will be for a small party. And I want it not only to look great, but taste just as great! I was looking at some places online like Susie Cakes and Hansen's. What does everyone else think? Oh, and nothing too pricey. The cake is an additional thing, not the main event! I appreciate any input and thanks in advance!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I love Susie Cakes. Their birthday cakes are delicious and the custom decorating is amazing. This is the go-to place in our family ( a large family) for celebration cakes. I do not like Hansen's. Their decorations are great but their cakes and icings are too sickeningly sweet for my taste. I have had great success serving the Susie Cakes 7-layer chocolate cake with a bit of writing and decoration on top. Always, a clear winner.

    1. I also don't like Hansen's...worst cake I've tasted in L.A., and the customer service is terrible to boot. I really like Lido Bakery in Manhattan Beach, but this may be too far from wherever you are located.

      4 Replies
      1. re: Nicole

        Is Lido Bakery related to Lido di Manhattan Restaurant by chance? The one by the Houston's?

        1. re: Yes Please

          Lido bakery is a small family-owned and run business, so I don't think there is any relation, despite the shared name and geographic proximity.

          1. re: Yes Please

            The family that owns/runs Lido worked for Sweet Lady Jane for quite a few years. You'll find a lot of similarities between the cakes of the two places, but all of the negatives at SLJ are non-existent at Lido. Great tasting and looking cakes, reasonable prices, nice folks. You can order by the slice to try them out - they are very generous with their slices.

            1. re: Yes Please

              Adding the link:

              Lido Bakery
              3001 N Sepulveda Blvd, D Manhattan Beach, CA 90266

          2. Where are you?

            If you're in South Bay, (or like organic stuff) CAKE BAKESHOP can pro'lly help you out:

            Otherwise, I second Susie cakes, and also recommend HOT CAKE ( which ahve always done right by me.

            8 Replies
            1. re: JackonCrack

              I'm in Marina Del Rey. I don't mind driving a little if it'll be worth it. But within LA County would be best!

              1. re: Yes Please

                The Viktor Benes bakery in Gelson's has a good reputation. I've had plenty of things from there that were quite good - just in case you don't find the perfect freestanding bakery. They aren't inexpensive though. Costco cakes supposedly have a good taste reputation too and would be easier on the cost. I'm not a fan of the traffic around those places though!

                If you are up for almost any kind of cake, I should just mention that I've had wonderful strawberries-and-whipped-cream cakes from an Asian bakery - I'm sure there are several threads around with info on those kind. Very light, very fresh, very different vs. the conventional birthday cake options.

                Here's another thread with some fairly recent posts about good cake spots in L.A.

                1. re: Cinnamon

                  >>If you are up for almost any kind of cake, I should just mention that I've had wonderful strawberries-and-whipped-cream cakes from an Asian bakery...<<

                  If the cake was from the Westside, it was most likely Angel Maid.

                  Angel Maid Bakery
                  4538 S Centinela Ave, Los Angeles, CA

                  1. re: bulavinaka

                    also get some cream puffs there for the ride home

                  2. re: Cinnamon

                    i've bought some good cakes from viktor bene's at gelsons in the past, but DON'T get anything made with apples. for some reason their apple filling is overly sweet and overly cooked--reminiscent of something that comes from a can. everything else has been fine.

                  3. re: Yes Please

                    A couple more bakeries that are within a reasonable distance from you areJamaica's Cakes and Buttercake Bakery, both on Pico in West LA. Jamaica's Cakes finishes a lot of their cakes with fondant and have a more refined look, while Buttercake often finishes their cakes with butter cream frosting and look more home made (in a good way). Both are very good, both sell cakes by the slice so you can sample and decide - tough job.

                    1. re: bulavinaka

                      My last cake purchase at Jamaica's Cakes was terrible. I ordered a red velvet with a simple ballon design ($70) for my son's 1st Bday and the cake was dry as a bone.

                      To be fair, we've ordered from them before without any problems.

                      However, if a cake shop royally screws up a red velvet, there off of my list for good.

                      1. re: vinosnob

                        I hope you brought up this problem to them. I have never had anything so dry as you described from Jamaica's Cakes. And I'm sure they would not have sold you this cake had they known it was so bad. I've had their red velvet cupcakes and they were extremely moist. I'm no expert on red velvet, but they tasted awfully good as well. If you haven't, you really should talk with them...

                2. The original comment has been removed
                  1. I have heard some not so nice things about Sweet Lady Jane, although I've never been so I can't speak from experience. But berry cake sounds yummy! Is it better than Susina's??

                    1. re: Yes Please

                      I can second that "not-so-nice" stuff about Lady Jane's ~ they act like they're doing you a favor when they wait on you! Susina anything is fantastic, & they're super user-friendly. However, my favorite best-kept-secret place is, actually, right in the Marina, on Centinela. It's called Angel Maid, & their cakes are amazing, & not too pricey. I had a bit of trouble with them misplacing an order last year, but we did resolve it amicably, so I'm totally a fan again.

                    2. Sweet Lady Jane has been widely reviled on this site and, I think, justifiably so. I'd think long and hard before setting foot in there. Bad attitude leads to bad product.

                      1. re: farmertomato

                        I absolutely cannot agree with your supposition that "bad attitude leads to bad product," especially at SLJ. True, the attitude can be less than desirable, but their product is superb. I think the only reason they're able to stay in business is because their cakes are so superior to anything else out there. Terrible customer service and exorbitant prices should be a recipe for disaster. They must be doing something right. Their cakes are that good.

                        1. re: pinpei

                          <<True, the attitude can be less than desirable, but their product is superb. I think the only reason they're able to stay in business is because their cakes are so superior to anything else out there.<<

                          This may or may not be true - everyone is entitled to their opinion, particularly when it comes to taste. I used to regularly enjoy their goods, but three things eventually turned me away from there.

                          1) Their service. No need to expand on this.

                          2) Their prices. Granted, if things are fresh, their quality in general is pretty good to great, but it can be spotty, in which case I'm not willing to shell out top-dollar for.

                          3) Their quality. As mentioned above, this can sway depending on what you get. In particular, their Triple Berry Shortcake (which is one of their best selling cakes) can be great or have a really off-taste. My gut tells me that they might be recycling their cakes that have been returned from Gelson's or where ever else they're offering them outside of their shop. I can't vouch for this recently because I haven't been in almost two years now.

                          1. re: bulavinaka

                            Two years? Maybe you should give them another try. Still, the service hasn't changed.

                    3. I have not been there for a while but the El Segundo Bakery was always a great place for cakes ..they used to do a special request cake that was chocolate cake with whipped cream and fresh banana filling that was always a major is not far from the marina at all.

                      El Segundo Bakery
                      219 W Grand Ave, El Segundo, CA 90245

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: dendet

                        El Segundo Bakery is closed - I think the family decided to shut it down and retire...