I just picked some up for lunch today at Edison Cafe and while it's fine, it certainly isn't great. Any suggestions for where I can go? I'm open to Outer Boroughs as well and will post this there too.
Sables on 2nd Ave has homemade gefilte fish that does not even come close the the kind in the jar.
Russ and DaughtersKatz's Zabar'sI do think it depends on the time of year though.
I was in Zabar's yesterday and noticed it in the prepared refrigerated section(the one closest to the checkouts)
Also, Citarella's has great gefilte fish...don't know if they make it year round.Call and ask 212.874.0383
Do all or some of these places make it wrapped in carp skin, or is it more like what you get in jars?
Most Recommended Discussions on Manhattan
Apr 17, 2014
Why so confusing to pay @ katz...
about 11 hours ago
A Great Cheap Breakfast in the...
about 20 hours ago
Where can I get a great tuna...
about 22 hours ago
Visiting from Toronto - thoughts...
about 8 hours ago
2 days ago
2014 Pebble Beach Food & Wine Festival
See All 23 Recipes »
About/Contact CHOW |
Posting Guidelines |
CBS Entertainment | About CBS Interactive | Jobs | Advertise