Does anyone know where I can find Vanilla Coke in the City? I have a niece visiting me for the summer and she is really craving some. I searched the board and tried the Rite Aid suggestion from 2007, but they don't have it. I've also tried 7-Eleven, Duane Reede, Food Emporium and some local grocers.
I just wanted to thank you guys! My niece loved both the Vanilla Coke at Lexington Candy Shop and the Egg Cream at Gem Spa. We also found bottled Vanilla Coke at Danny's (right next to the W hotel) on 47th St right off Broadway (toward 8th), in case anyone is looking for it!
The Lexington Candy Shop makes coke the old fashioned way, and that includes Vanilla Coke:
I love this place - it's (too) expensive for what it is, and the food is decent but not great, but it has such a great nostalgia feel. I'm in there about once a week these days!