HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Discussion

June 2009 COTM Elizabeth David Classics: Hors d’oeuvres & Salads

  • 25
  • Share

Welcome to Elizabeth David Classics, which includes these three books by Elizabeth David:

A Book of Mediterranean Food [M] - "Cold Foods & Salads" (Salads only here, please)
Summer Cooking [S] - "Hors d'oeuvres" & "Salads"
French Country Cooking [F] - "Vegetables" (Sub-section called "Salads" only, please)

Please post your full-length reviews of recipes here for recipes in chapters with Hors 'd'oeuvres, Vegetables or Salads here. If a recipe for one of these items appears in a chapter without any of those three items in the title, please post it here anyway, unless it more aptly fits into another category. Since there are a number of different editions and some posters have the individual books, please post the abbreviations for the books as listed above, and the name of the recipe, as well as any modifications you made to the recipe. That way posters can then look up the recipe in the index of whichever book they have.

A reminder that the verbatim copying of recipes to the boards is a violation of the copyright of the original author. Posts with copied recipes will be removed.

Thanks for participating!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. Chicken liver paté, Summer Cooking

    In the introduction to my edition, it says that ED's method of making this classic has been much tinkered with, but never bettered, and I would agree with that. I'd also say this is a perfect dinner party dish - economical but still impressive, and, most importantly, it HAS to be made in advance. ED says at least a couple of days, and it will last for weeks in the fridge if you seal it with butter.

    Anyway, very easy. You cook a pound of chicken livers in butter and then pound them in a mortar. I am a new-fangled girl and used a food processor. You add brandy (I used armagnac as we're out of brandy) to the butter and juices left in the pan and bubble for a minute, before adding port. Bubble again and then add to the livers, with more butter, a small clove of garlic, a bit of thyme and S&P. Process until smooth and then transfer to a terrine and chill. My top tip stolen from Simon Hopkinson is to use foil takeaway containers if you don't have a terrine - the bonus is that it's very easy to turn out for a professional looking finish. One of my guests thought I'd bought the paté from a deli! If you want to keep it for more than a couple of days, ED suggests melting butter or pork or goose fat and pouring a thin layer on top of the paté to seal it.

    Delicious as a first course with hot toast and a little salad garnish. And cheap, even if you use organic chicken livers like I did (about £1.50 a pound).

    1. Eggs in Aspic with Tarragon (S).

      Well per my own "rules" (!) I'm putting this in this thread, as it comes in the hors d'oeuvres chapter of Summer Cooking, but would also make a nice "luncheon dish" as well. Well, it would if it turned out nicely!

      I made aspic per another recipe of hers, and will post about it separately. I also poached some eggs her way, based on another recipe, and will post about that too. I'd never made this dish before, so I consulted with Mastering the Art of French Cooking as well, and put some together ED's way, and some per Julia Child.

      Per E. David's recipe:

      You put a slice of very mild ham at the bottom of a small ramekin (I cut out circles using the ramekin as a template), then put the poached egg on top, and several tarragon leaves in some melted aspic for an hour and let them infuse. I did this first though, and then started the assembly process. Then strain the aspic and pour it "very carefully" into the ramekins "and when it has nearly set" put two fresh tarragon on top of the egg. Note that there are no instructions here about chilling the dish. My aspic turned out quite nicely, but it did not gel completely at room temperature (not sure that it can?). Knowing this, I followed her instructions but then refrigerated the ramekins. She also doesn't say anything about turning out the egg etc. on to a plate, which is how I've usually seen this dish.

      JC's instructions are sort of the reverse - pour some aspic into the ramekin, let it set up a bit in the fridge, garnish (I used the tarragon leaves), add the poached egg, some more aspic, set up some more, add the slice of ham, let chill, then release onto a plate. This way, you get the pretty design on top, then the egg, then the ham, and I have to say I think this way makes more sense to me.

      Neither of us liked the result, and we have both had the dish before, and liked it. My thoughts as to why:

      Far too much aspic - I thought I was using small enough ramekins (4 oz?), but I would use smaller ones next time, or not fill them up so much.

      Aspic not salty enough.

      Would be better made the day before, so that they can really set up nicely.

      I do want to try to make this again though.

      1. Ratatouille en Salade from [S].

        Well it mentions that ED's recipe is meant to be served cold but I decided to eat it warm over brown rice. I also used Japanese eggplants because I had a few in my kitchen and added ground coriander seed rather than whole coriander seeds. I wasn't sure about the amount of olive oil to use but since I halved the recipe (cooking for one), about 1/4 cup seemed about right.

        This was a really simple ratatouille and I liked the consistency and taste. I could see it being great cold for a packed picnic. I would definitely make it again.

         
        3 Replies
        1. re: always_eating

          I made this for dinner tonight, it was delicious! I also used Japanese eggplant, and served it hot, with panko breaded chicken and rice. Fresh basil made it perfection.

           
          1. re: yamalam

            Okay that chicken looks yum! Great pic. What else did you put in your rice btw?

            1. re: always_eating

              It's arroz frito, where you fry 1/8 or so of the rice grains before continuing to make rice as usual. Brings out a nice nuttiness

        2. Salad of aubergines (M)

          This is a good example of why ED was so groundbreaking. It's 1950 or thereabouts and Britain has undergone years of rationing (anyone interested in what culinary aberrations this brought about should seek out Marguerite Patten, a wonderful lady who is still alive). Olive oil is only available in the chemist and garlic is a nasty thing that foreigners eat. Most British people have probably never heard of an aubergine, never mind eaten one.

          And ED gives us a recipe for salad of aubergine, which is actually what we now call baba ganoush! The recipe calls for grilling 3 or 4 large aubergines until soft, and pounding them in a mortar with garlic, then adding olive oil as if for mayonnaise, until you get a thick purée. I used my blender and found I didn't need that much oil at all. You then add the juice of half a lemon, which brings the flavours together nicely, and some chopped parsley.

          I served this as part of a meze with flatbread, which three of us really enjoyed. Mr GG turned his nose up somewhat - brown sludge I believe were his words! It's very garlicky, and even more so now it's been in the fridge overnight (I will admit here that I had some for breakfast!) so I might cut the garlic down to one clove next time.

          2 Replies
          1. re: greedygirl

            I have always thought that the earlier books must have been the food porn of their time, given what was available at the time in the stores. The thought of some of these dishes must have driven the deprived, ration-ridden reader with memories of prewar conditions round the twist.

            1. re: buttertart

              Apart from I don't think they'd really been exposed to a lot of the ingredients even pre-war, like olive oil and a lot of the Mediterranean fish. She writes somewhere that many people had been put off fish by terrible "nursery food" experiences of boiled cod. Bream and the like must have seemed terribly avant-garde. But yes, all that butter and cream - torture for a population that had to survive on poor-quality substitutes and powdered egg. Of course, we take it all for granted now....

              OT but I visited the war museum in Dunkirk recently and was struck by one of the stories of a soldier who became separated from his unit and happened upon some French Resistance fighters. They welcomed him with open arms and treated him to a very civilised meal, with plenty of wine, which they'd apparently been storing in decommissioned tanks! It must have been the best meal he'd eaten for years, if ever.

          2. Salade Armenienne [F]

            What an interesting combination of vegetables are brought together to make a salad that is more room temperature than cold. In fact ED says, "don't spoil the flavour by putting it in the icebox." We loved it!

            1/2 lb mushrooms, 2 rashers bacon, garlic, parsley, pimentos, celery, and a glass of wine are the ingredients. The mushrooms are sliced and sauteed in 2 Ts of oil. Add a few very fine slivers of garlic (I used 3 cloves!), and bacon cut into squares (I used pancetta) and cook for a few minutes then add 6 oz. red wine. She says to "cook fiercely for just 1 minute." The flame is turned to low and the pan simmered for 5 minutes. A handful of chopped parsley is added, combined and the pan is left to cool.

            At this point I prepared the main dish, Coutelletes de Porc au Cidre. The gap in preparation time was perfect. When the chops were in the oven I proceeded to fill a shallow bowl with a sliced red bell pepper and about 10 stalks of celery sliced in 1/2 rounds. This is dressed with oil and "a drop" of tarragon vinegar. Well, after tasting this I seasoned it agressively, as Mario Batali is forever saying, with sea salt and FGTellecherry pepper and a few more "drops" of the vinegar. When the mushrooms have cooled down they are piled on top if the mushroom mixture. The salad is kept cool but not cold.

            This is a make again recipe. I can see it used all summer long. It probably would go very well with grilled meats of a hearty flavor.

            3 Replies
            1. re: Gio

              Salade au Chapon, p. 173 of my edition of French Country Food

              This was a very simple addition to a green salad that I used to make quite often. Somehow it vanished from my repertoire. Pieces of bread or toast are rubbed with raw garlic and put into the bottom of the salad bowl. The lettuce, etc. (in my case I used Persian cukes, green onion, green pepper, a few leaves of radichio from my csa box and some curly lettuce. I dressed it with a simple vinaigrette - just olive oil, red wine vinager, salt and pepper.

              It is really nice. The toasted bread absorbs some of the dressing and the salad absorbs some of the garlic.

              I made my version of Jerked Chicken and that was dinner.

              1. re: Gio

                Gio, I made the 'Armenienne' this afternoon and was disappointed--until I waited about an hour and a half--then it was great! , At first the celery seemed all alone and a little bitter, but the bacon commingled everything nicely after a while. How good mushrooms are cooked in wine!

                1. re: blue room

                  <"When the mushrooms have cooled down they are piled on top if the mushroom mixture.">

                  I won't tell you how many times I proof read this post.... I meant to say,"when the mushrooms cool down they are piled on top of the celery and pepper mixture.">

                  I think the cooling down and then mixing all together is the key. I have always sauteed mushrooms in evoo, garlic and white wine with a bit of chopped parsley, so was interested to taste the flavor difference here. I'm so glad the wait made all the difference for you......

              2. Ratatouille en Salade [S]

                My husband insisted that I buy some Japanese eggplants and bok choy yesterday, but I really didn't want to have an Asian inspired meal, so convinced him to leave the bok choy for another day. I started browsing through David to see what to do with the eggplants, and since I had a red pepper hanging around, as well as some grape tomatoes, I forged ahead - making half the recipe. I sauted one chopped onion in olive oil (she says a tumbler of olive oil - no idea how much that is), then added the two eggplants, one red pepper (both cut into .5 inch squares) and a little more olive oil. I decided that I didn't think these eggplants needed salting, so I didn't. This gets cooked with the lid on for about 30 - 40 minutes, then you add the tomatoes (I just cut the grape tomatoes in half), coriander seeds (6) and garlic - I just smashed a garlic clove and threw it in. The mixture then continues to cook until the tomatoes "have melted". I did not cool it completely, but stirred in some chopped parsley just before serving, and then served on a bed of arugula. I did add salt & pepper along the way. I don't think I've ever made ratatouille before and loved this. Also a great dish to make ahead of time.

                 
                1 Reply
                1. re: MMRuth

                  Just realized that someone had posted about this recipe above. Anyway - the next day I grilled a piece of bread and added some thinly sliced smoked mozzarella, olive oil, arugula and then piled on the ratatouille.

                   
                2. Cucumber and Chive Salad [S]

                  I used 4 Persian cucumbers, and then added some leftover micro cress as well, as I wanted to use it up. She says to use a mandoline to make paper thin slices of peeled cucumbers, but I don't have one and used what I usually use in these instances - my truffle shaver. The cucumber slices get tossed with salt and left to drain for thirty minutes. The quantities for the dressing are, well, not given for the most part. I started w/ 1 tsp sugar dissolved in 1 tsp vinegar (you are supposed to use tarragon vinegar, which I didn't have, so I used Champagne vinegar and added some fresh tarragon later). I then added some heavy cream, salt & pepper. I thought it was far too sweet, and added a bit more cream and a smidgen of vinegar and then stirred in olive oil and chopped chives and tarragon. Next time I think I'd start with 1/2 teaspoon of sugar instead. You are supposed to pour the dressing over the cucumbers, but I just poured some of it on, and tossed the salad. This was lovely with the steamed Arctic char that I made (which I smeared with some left over chive butter from the beets I've been making).

                   
                   
                  4 Replies
                  1. re: MMRuth

                    Very pretty salad!
                    What do you think the cream added? Tempered some of the vinegar?

                    (One of my favorite cucumber salads is salted cucumber (drained and rinsed), red onion set in rice vinegar to temper) w/ a bit of sugar. There are also Asian variations, including I believe Oseland(? -- as in pickles) Tarragon seems to be a nice flavor addition.

                    BTW, what's the lump between your (beautiful) fish and salad?

                    1. re: NYchowcook

                      The lump is walnut sauce - haven't gotten to that one yet, but it's from the Summer Sauces chapter. I added quite a bit of cream - I think it is really the base of sauce, and adds, well, creaminess. ;-) It doesn't look so creamy in the photo, but it did in the bowl in which I made the sauce.

                      1. re: MMRuth

                        MMRuth--to clarify for myself--you added cream to the walnut sauce, from Summer Cooking?
                        I want to try that one too since she says it's good with fish, but I it doesn't contain any cream.

                        recipe

                        1. re: blue room

                          No - the cream is in the dressing for the cucumber and chive salad. I still need to report on the walnut sauce, though it was a mixed bag. Will try to do in the am.

                  2. Patafla, Mediterranean Food (in Cold Food and Salads)
                    This is a sandwich that contains no meat, no cheese, no mayo, no butter. But it seems decadent, not "lite". It's a hollowed out loaf filled with chopped tomato, onion, olives (black and green), gherkins, capers, pimento. *Make it the day before you need it, no fail.* Mix all the chopped vegetables with the torn up bread you removed, season it with black pepper and salt (easy on the salt!-- some of the ingredients are already salty) drizzle some olive oil into it. A pinch of paprika. Then fill the hollow loaf and refrigerate 'til tomorrow, when it can be sliced and served. (I wrapped it in plastic wrap.)
                    To me, a gherkin is a sweet pickle--I wonder if it was the same to ED. Also, I wonder if a pimento meant a red bell pepper to ED. I tried to stick close to her original recipe for COTM . My first capers! vinegary, salty-- I wonder what they're like fresh--are they ever eaten fresh? Lol--what are they FOR?
                    I used bread I like from my Whole Foods -- it's called "Rustic Italian" (ED said "A long French loaf"). So the finished product was probably messier--less compact-- than it should have been. (ED said it would be good for a cocktail party or a picnic, so there might not be a plate at hand...)
                    Anyway, it's delicious, I'll definitely do it again, try many ingredient variations.
                    Sandwiches like this I think are sometimes pressed--weighted to insure the juices get soaked up by the bread, but ED didn't mention this. (She *did* use the word "frigidaire"!)

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: blue room

                      Gherkin is more likely a cornichon, I think the sweet ones are of North American origin?

                      1. re: buttertart

                        That reminds me - her recipes often call for "a pickled cucumber". Is this something one regularly finds in the U.K. - i.e., a whole one?

                    2. Salade Espagnole [S]

                      Bless her heart, brevity is Elizabeth David's forte. Six simple ingredients, three lines in the book. Wish I could do as well.

                      Boil some potatoes (I used a bag of fingerlings and steamed them). Slice them and mix with EVOO, lemon juice ( I juiced a whole lemon), S&P, and a chopped small shallot. I placed all this on a platter and as instructed, covered the whole "completely" with sliced tomatoes. The garnish is thin rings of raw green pepper. I didn't do this. RGP and I don't agree.

                      An unexpected way to serve potato salad. It went well with the Champignons Chevenols and cold lobster.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: Gio

                        This sounds simple and good. I suppose mayo & chopped yellow onion & chopped egg is what "happened" to this treatment of potatoes . I'll try this too.