HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Thoughts on Rouge Tomate?

KiwiGirl625 May 19, 2009 08:22 AM

Has anyone been here? Any thoughts?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. e
    ExFlexitarian RE: KiwiGirl625 May 19, 2009 08:30 AM

    Guessing you watched that Gossip Girl ep as well?

    1. c
      calconscious RE: KiwiGirl625 May 19, 2009 12:11 PM

      don't know anything about Gossip Girl - but have been to Rouge Tomate. It was very nice - the food did feel healthy and taste good - very important to me; however, I did find it expensive and (no right or wrong here - just personal preference) a little too UES nobody's forehead moves - it felt pretentious for lunch - now, if it were dinner - well that I would understand <g>. In sum I really liked the food - but not the vibe.

      3 Replies
      1. re: calconscious
        emma RE: calconscious May 19, 2009 03:19 PM

        i thought it was definitely overpriced.

        1. re: calconscious
          KiwiGirl625 RE: calconscious May 20, 2009 07:16 AM

          What did you have when you ate there?

          1. re: KiwiGirl625
            emma RE: KiwiGirl625 May 22, 2009 09:32 AM

            probably not a good thing i absolutely could not remember without looking the menu up online, eh? i had the tuna poke app and halibut. they were serviceable but, as i said, way way overpriced. i think they are trying to be a very high-scale restaurant when they just.. aren't, food and service-wise. i had a tasty cocktail and the space is very, very pretty. so perhaps it is just a nice place to get a drink.

        2. d
          David W RE: KiwiGirl625 May 22, 2009 02:20 PM

          I ate there awhile ago and don't remeber what I ate, either--and it is expensive and they tried to charge more on the bill than what was shown on the menu-I only caught it because my wife had said something about the cost of one of the dishes when I said I was going to order it...it was, like, $3 more on the bill...they took it off once I mentioned it, but really...
          I'd agree the space is pretty nice-maybe a drink, and dinner elsewhere.

          3 Replies
          1. re: David W
            mcoleman RE: David W Jun 28, 2009 05:38 AM

            went last night and didn't like the space itself -- too big antiseptic and EMPTY. but the food was fantastic, right from the amuse shooter of asparagus soup, not rich just the essence of vegetable. my wife started w/white gazpacho special which didn't seem esp. spanish and was actually green but tasted of almonds and I don't what else. I began w/heirloom tomato and watermelon salad, also include cukes a few olive slivers and a crumble of mild feta. perfect.
            she had the farotto w/porcini and spring veg as an entree, smallish portion but very filling and enjoyable (I didn't sample this) while I had the duck sous vide, w/greens parsnips and a wedge potato roesti that wasn't the usual buttery gutbuster. (disclaimer: I am not as enamored of fat/richness as many chowhounders, so take this w/a grain of salt or pat of butter). the duck was straight forward and perfectly textured, medium rare w/o rawness.
            washed it down w/a tasty glass of granache (her) and a well-executed gin martini (me).

            somewhat pricey and probably not worth a special trip to east midtwon, but we were pleasantly surprised by the quality of food.

            1. re: mcoleman
              Snaps RE: mcoleman Jun 28, 2009 05:59 AM

              we really liked all the food we had, but found that dining in a giantly huge overpriced restaurant at about e20% capacity killed the experience. we kept talking about how there is no way this place will stay in business for long.

              1. re: Snaps
                mcoleman RE: Snaps Jun 28, 2009 06:28 AM

                exactly. maybe it's a business lunch spot? still it seems doomed...

          Show Hidden Posts