Best casual French in Boston?
Just got back from an amazing trip to Paris (including meals at several Michelin 3-stars!) and are now longing for delicious, authentic French here in our own fair city. Of Gaslight, Aquitaine, Brasserie Jo, Bouchee, or LaVoile, what do you think is the best French bistro? What other places do we have that am I forgetting?
None of those are what I'd call traditional Parisian bistro. La Voile is Southern/Nicoise, Gaslight and Brasserie Jo are brasseries and hence lean Alsatian, Aquitaine is more New American accented, and Bouchee seems kind of Epcot Center France to me.
More dead-on traditional are the Petit Roberts, Pierrot, Beacon Hill Bistro, and Les Zygomates. These come closest in feel, menu, and price to the Parisian ideal.
Also worthy and fairly moderately priced: Sel de la Terre (kind of upmarket country French), Sandrine's (more purely Alsatian), Troquet (wine-centric), Chez Henri (restaurant side, which has some South American accents), Kingston Station, and Jasmine Bistro (half the menu).
French in technique but more local/New American focused and pricey but not formal-feeling: Salts, Lumiere, Hamersley's, Craigie on Main, T.W. Food.
Not really casual, but since we're at it:
Upscale and New American accented: Radius, Pigalle.
Nouvelle, fancy and pricey: L'Espalier, Sensing, Aujourd'hui.
French-ish, fussy, fusion-y, and pricey: Clio, Mantra, Banq.
Of the places you mention, I like Brasserie Jo the best for French authenticity. I would also add Petit Robert to your list.
I used to like Sandrines very much for French/Alsatian food, although I found that it went downhill so precipitously from when it first opened that I haven't been back for some years. Maybe it's gotten better again?
I also like Brasserie Jo, and agree that it leans towards the Alsatian side. However, it definately has the feel of a french brasserie and the food is very well done. Actually the worst thing i have had there was the most alsatian of dishes- choucroute. It seemed like a heap of saurkraut served with some grilled meats. It is supposed to be meat stewed in the kraut with beer, wine, juniper, etc. EVERYTHING else i Have had there has been spot on though. Classic steak frites and amazing Coq au vin. Great selection of French and Belgian beers too.
Hammersley's Bistro is also an option- amazing food, but you won't necessarily find straight up bistro favorites. Chef Gordon Hammersley puts his flair on all of the french classics. In my opinion, this is what makes it authentic. Regardless of what is technically a bistro or not, Hammersley's is a great place to eat French inspired food.
I did a similar search after a trip to Paris last year.
IMO, Petit Robert, LaVoile and Brasserie Jo come closest. I have not been to Pierrot, but it's supposed to be quite good.
I used to eat at Les Zygomates fairly often (before they opened their Italian sibling) and IMO the closest it comes to a real French bistro are the decorations.
Avoid Bouchee. "Epcot Center France " is spot-on commentary.
Brasserie Jo, Gaslight, Petit Robert Bistro (Needham) in that order. BJ, particularly, is where I've always had good meals, professional service and reasonable prices.
Probably more brasserie than bistro in style (but a bit too expensive to really count as one) is Eastern Standard. Either French with New American accents or vice versa.
All the bistro classics, good oysters, great cocktails, solid wine program.
My vote would go to Sandrine's, they make excellent terrines and fois gras, and their steak is fantastic. The menu as noted is heavily alsatian-influenced but there are a few reliably wonderful bistro style meals on the menu. I also love Hammersley's, and agree with what is posted below (it's not strictly french, but a great interpretation of the bistro experience.