Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
May 9, 2009 10:33 AM


Hi all going to WD-50 next week and was wondering if I should go with the tasting menu or order a la carte? I have read several post out here regarding the restaurant and some are dated or plain confusing on the issue. Any help would be greatly appreciated - thanks Jay

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Although we've ordered from both (and enjoyed both for different reasons), you should order the tasting menu. That is truly where chef Dufresne (sp?) shows his artistry.

    1. I agree with Berna. Go with the tasting menu, especially since it's your first time and you seem unafraid of adventure. The a la carte options tend to be more mainstream and 'accessible', but they tend to be less interesting than the tasting menu.

      1. I had the tasting menu 4 weeks back. It was very good, I went with the wine as well but felt overall that it was a bit expensive.

        I would do the tasting menu again, however would probably pick up a bottle under their "Bacchus" deal at half price or go with cocktails.

        Its not that their wine choices were not amazing but we came in at 600$ or so and thats a lot for a very interesting but casual dinner.

        1. Tasting menu. I have eaten there a bunch of times and EVERYTIME the tasting menu was fantastic and EVERYTIME (twice) I went a la carte I was disappointed.

          1. The current tasting menu is very strong.

            I (230lb guy who likes to drink) tend to get drunk when I get the pairings so I definitely recommend using the discount to get a bottle or two.