Bellissimo on Esplanade
Can't speak to the service as I have only ordered it in. I have had Bellissimo's many times, and I agree that it wasn't as good there for awhile. However, I had it this past weekend and it was delicious. Much better than the last couple of times - the crust wasn't too thick (i.e. it was actually cooked through). Maybe it depends on who is making the pizza, which is a bad thing. I think I will try some of the other posters' suggestions though :)
I used to enjoy the Bellissimo pizzas. The last two times I ordered delivery it was as though they were a completely different pizzeria. You cannot undercook a thick crust pizza and expect the experience to be enjoyable. The toppings seemed cheaper.
Now when I want the silver stand of pizza I go to Olympic 76. Consistently good pizza. Not sure I'd eat anything else there.
8A Gloucester St, Toronto, ON M4Y1L5, CA
It's a cozy neighbourhood place but the pizza is not that great, in my opinion. Really thick crust, loaded with sauce and toppings, but none of it tastes like much. The cheese is not high quality. I think kids and teens probably think it's great, but after being spoiled by nice crispy crusts and tasty toppings I can't get into it.
The burgers there are pretty good, though. And I love the smalltown feel of this place, as well as Times Square a few blocks west (with good fish and chips, yes I'm straying way off topic here...)