Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >
Apr 27, 2009 04:30 PM

what's going on with blue pig in croton?

Their phone number has been disconnected and the last few times I've driven by it's been closed. Anyone been there lately (in the last few weeks or so)?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Well, that does not sound good. We haven't been in years, since the original owners sold the place and got rid of what we considered to be the interesting flavors, like coconut.

    I still remember the first time I had their ice cream, at a benefit performance of Baby at the Irvington Town Hall Theater. It was a week or so before they opened.

    7 Replies
    1. re: MisterBill2

      I never went until about 2 years ago, and their dam dark chocolate is reason enough for many repeat visits. Yum! I really hope it's temporary. We ended up going to Quimbaya, and their ice cream isn't homemade, so it just wasn't the same. I might even be forced to try Purple Monkey if I get really desperate.

      1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

        Haven't tried it, but Purple Monkey sounds less than great. Try the gelato place in Ossining, opposite Milwood Lumber. YUMMY!

        1. re: Nancy C

          Oh yeah! I totally forgot about the gelato place in my ice cream fervor.

          1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

            I know they usually close for the winter, but shouldn't they be open by now?

            1. re: elleinthecity

              I went about a month ago, after they had reopened from being "away at ice cream university." She had only a few flavors.

          2. re: Nancy C

            Why does Purple Monkey sound less than great? We tried it the other day, and really enjoyed it--we had Maine blueberry, rum raisin and moose something or other...the ice cream was fresh, creamy, served by a pleasant person, and less expensive than Blue Pig. On more than one occasion, I have had icy, mediocre ice cream at Blue Pig. I was recently turned off by some internet postings ostensibly by Blue Pig owners/employees/fans complaining about Purple Monkey...among other laments, was how dare they take on the name of a colored animal!?!? Puhleez....I think competition is far, my experience is that Purple Monkey has delicious ice cream, gives a generous portion, at a more reasonable price, and they're not open at erratic times.

            1. re: Marge

              I also enjoyed it very much Marge. I agree, competition keeps everyone on their toes.

      2. I passed by the blue pig earlier today, and it was open! Curious though, why would desperation drive you to try the purple monkey--what's wrong with it??

        8 Replies
        1. re: Marge

          Thanks for the update. I guess I should try Purple Monkey. For no good reason (other than it's not homemade, but that doesn't keep me from Baskin Robbins when there's no other optioN!) I've been averse to trying it. How is it?

          1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

            I haven't tried it yet--I am an afficianado of the gelato joint for my Ossining ice cream fixes.

            1. re: Marge

              So I finally tried Purple Monkey last night, at the urging of my sister, and I have to say it was pretty good! According to the Journal News, it is not made in the store, but it is homemade by a family in Maine.

              It is cheaper than Blue Pig, but Blue Pig has those enormous fresh waffle cones drenched in chocolate and sprinkles which I cannot resist. (Overheard at Blue Pig: "Mommy, why can't I get one of those sprinkle cones?" -whining kid "Because I'm the worst mother ever!" -mom) Blue Pig has fewer flavors, but they do have interesting ones in the rotation. Purple Monkey definitely has more flavors, and they do biggggg scoops.

              My loyalty will remain with Blue Pig, but I'm glad I tried Purple Monkey and I'd definitely go back.

              Unrelated to ice cream-- Okinawa, a hibachi place, is slated to open where a teen clothing place used to be in the same shopping center. I'm skeptical.

              1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

                Seems like alot of hibachi places have been poping up in the last couple years. Is Okinawa going in the Arcadian Shopping Center? There is another one going in on Central Ave in Hartsdale and I think I saw another one just opened up (can't remember where), I saw an ad in the Clipper or one of those magazines.

                1. re: GIOny

                  Yep, Arcadian, that's it, I couldn't remember the name.

                  1. re: GIOny

                    There's another Okinawa in Yorktown. I ate lunch there once and was not impressed. I really like Tengda in Katonah, their lunch menu is particularly reasonably priced (and huge portions).

                  2. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

                    My daughter went to Purple Monkey today and said it was good but the flavors were not as interesting as Blue Pig (or at least what they used to be, we have not been there in a LONG time, since they were sold).

                    1. re: MisterBill2

                      I went to Purple Monkey over the weekend and I thought the ice cream was good. It was creamy and it had taste (some places serve ice cream that tastes like ice milk). I had the heavenly hash and I enjoyed it, I also loved the decor, very cute.

            2. i just went there . they are open!

              1. I went last week and they were open. They had a bunch of new flavors, such as banana bread (yumm), and one of my favorites-- coconut butterfinger. I asked the owner about the phone situation and she said they have been having trouble with it and they're trying to resolve it. It's been like that for weeks now. Especially in less than perfect weather I like to call ahead instead of getting there and being disappointed that they're closed (they can be kind of fickle with hours), so I hope they fix it soon.

                6 Replies
                1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

                  i agree about the issue with the fickle hours. there are days when i need to satisfy my ice cream fix and then I get disappointed. Have you ever tried the ice cream place in tarrytown

                  1. re: shoekittykat

                    I agree also....a day or two ago I NEEDED ice cream, and Blue Pig was closed in the afternoon. The ice cream place in Tarrytown is really, really good.
                    edited to add--if you happen to be in Tarrytown...closer to Croton I love the gelato place in Ossining.

                    1. re: Marge

                      Where is the Purple Monkey?? There is a new ice cream place opening in Croton in the shopping plaza where Chase Bank/Memphis Maes/Coach Nails is. Not sure what the name will be but I saw them working in there and it looks like it should be done within a month or so.

                        1. re: GIOny

                          The Purple Monkey is in Arcadian Shopping Center in Ossining. They are also opening another one in Croton, which is the one you mentioned in your post. I haven't gotten to the one in Ossining yet, as I usually hit Main Street Sweets in Tarrytown to satisfy my ice cream fix.

                          1. re: ltlevy

                            Thanks for clarifying that, I didn't think they were opened up yet in Croton so I was confused.

                  2. I noticed there is a sign out in front that the Blue Pig is for sale.

                    9 Replies
                    1. re: Marge

                      Yes, the owner is getting married and moving to Albany. Business is fine. The Blue Pig is for sale including the recipes. I hope someone great buys it!

                      1. re: Elisa515

                        I sure hope so... the Purple Monkey is no competition to the Blue Pig as far as quality goes. I tned to prefer the gelato place in Ossining as a rule, even in comparison to the Blue Pig. Deer Tracks purchased at Purple Monkey yesterday seemed fridge-tasting.

                          1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

                            Me too! Hey - it could happen! Someone took over MED in Briarcliff (including the recipes) when the owner passed away. The Blue Pig is a great business. Someone will sweep it up - maybe the owners at Umami can pick it up - I think they use their ice cream exclusively.

                            1. re: Sra. Swanky

                              I didn't know that about MED being taken over-- that's great. What a sad story that was. I still have yet to try it. As for Blue Pig, here's hoping. Is it open in the interim?

                              1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

                                Yes Blue Pig is open. And yes Umami carries their ice cream exclusively. Had coconut butterfinger last night at Umami--yum!!!!!!

                              2. re: Sra. Swanky

                                trying to figure out what MED stands for?????

                                1. re: GIOny

                                  I think Marcelo picked Med as a shortening of the name American Empanada -- he said that every culture has its own version of the empanada. I remember one of his menus said, "The new name for the US empanada is MED." I'm so happy his family sold the place to people that will keep his recipes going.