Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Apr 24, 2009 01:48 PM

J. Kenji Alt's Boston Burger Battle

I haven't tried Flat Patties, but as a huge fan of the West Coast style burger I'm looking forward to trying it. I think Green St.'s double cheeseburger is a strong competitor for that style as well.

On the East Coast style, I'm glad to see someone agree that R.F. O'Sullivan's is totally over-rated.

Confusingly, his rankings seem to go from 1 - best to 10 - worst.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Newspapers can't report everything, but I think its a bit odd they didn't at least mention Bartley's. However, were I to do it some others which I would also consider are Mangia Mangia, Celebrity, and maybe Sully's for flat patties... Marlive (ditch the brioche, though), Christopher's (very inconsistent), and the Druid for pub burgers.

    8 Replies
    1. re: itaunas

      It's a "preview" of the magazine article so maybe there's more to come? He's written on Boston burgers before on AHT ( I'm too lazy to find specific links but you can just search for "Boston" and find mentions of some of those places

      Personally, I don't why you would mention Bartley's, other than to say that it's famous in spite of serving some of the worst food in town.

      1. re: bobot

        He also writes (one of the 2 people who do) at They had a great article about Craigie's burger on there last week.

        1. re: jgg13

          That blog is well worth reading on a regular basis.

          Sample quote from that Maws article about the Craigie burger: "By starting with three very flavorful and lean cuts of beef (he uses equal parts short rib, flap meat, and brisket), and adding in as much fat as you want (he goes with a ratio of around 85/15), you can get all the flavor of grass-fed beef combined with the juicy fat content of grain-fed beef. Best of both worlds." Whoa!

          1. re: MC Slim JB

            That passage alone had me trying to convince the gf that we need a meat grinder. So far, she who must be obeyed is resisting on lack of space arguments, but It'll happen. I liked the part about how they added fat in via suet & marrow.

      2. re: itaunas

        The Bartley's grease burger = blah. I like the burger on brioche with frites at Bouchee. Just wish they served it with bernaise sauce.

        1. re: robertlf

          I'm totally with you on this. I left out Bartley's on purpose because I think it's one of the most overrated burger joints in the city, if not country. Blah-city. The only reason I would have left it in would be so I could trash it and start a riot! About 90% of the responses I've got to that article are, "Great, but where's Bartley's?"

          1. re: kenjigoodeater

            A burger lover after my own heart. I seriously have never understood the praise Bartley's gets.

            1. re: BarmyFotheringayPhipps

              I'll be the outlier and stick up for Bartleys. I don't get there as often as I do other places on the list, but I agree with their slogan "you can't beat their meat". The quality of the chuck and the consistency of cooking to temp make this a solid burger choice, annoying crowds aside.

      3. Flat Patties is interesting to me. When I eat there (both burgers & pulled pork) I'll bite into them and say "eh, nothing special" but then I find that I can't put the things down and keep stuffing them in my face until they're gone. It's like there's crack in there or something. I've never really figured out how something that seems so plain ends up being such a must-have for me.

        re: O'Sullivans, my problem has always been their inconsistency on cooking levels. I always ask for "medium rare" and I might as well not bother because it seems like they're going to give me what they're going to give me anyways.

        re: rankings ... I didn't find it confusing. I viewed it as an ordered list, not a numerical score.

        3 Replies
        1. re: jgg13

          LOL. So true! I love Flat Patties!!!!!

          1. re: jgg13

            Well, because they're simple but perfectly done. They're not trying to expand the parameters of burgerdom or anything, they're just doing an excellent version of something that there isn't nearly nearly enough of around here.

            1. re: jgg13

              oh!!! I didn't realize it was an ordered list (*facepalm*) Now it makes perfect sense.

            2. Agree Green Street's burger deserves more attention. That's a very good burger, be it East Coast or West Coast style (I didn't know of this distinction -- did Alt make it up?)

              I saw the Craigie burger the other night and it does indeed look awesome. Bun a little too fluffy looking though -- it's not the dreaded brioche is it?

              Worst burger I've had lately was Boston Burger Co. in Davis. Dry. Really dry.

              5 Replies
              1. re: yumyum

                I had the Craigie burger in January and it was awesome. The bun is not brioche. Regarding its fluffiness perhaps someone else who has tried it should comment. I liked it but I admit I do like a brioche bun.

                1. re: yumyum

                  I admit - I did make it up, the East vs. West thing. It really comes down to grill vs. griddle, and in my experience, you see a lot more of the grill around here, and a lot more of the griddle out in CA. The west coast style of burger was invented out there too, in the 40's, right around the time that car culture was booming and people wanted fast, tasty food that wasn't too bulky to eat in the car. It spawned the likes of McDonald's, and eventually In-n-Out.

                  The article's a little overstaed - I am well aware that there are other regional styles of burgers. But in Boston, at least, up until a couple years ago, all you could get was the thick, grilled, pub-style burger (at least all you could get that was decent). It's only in the last few years that you can get a good, thin, griddled, drive-in diner style burger around here.

                  I haven't been to Boston Burger Co. (I flat out ban any place that uses the words "company" or "factory" in their name - with the exception of Jim Lahey's fabulous Co. in NY - best neapolitan pies in Manhattan), but if you want a really horrible burger experience, go to any of the B.Goods. Abominations of the highest order!

                  1. re: kenjigoodeater

                    Griddle cooked burgers were the norm in the country when I was growing up, which is why I find the high praise about a 5 Guys so odd: it's the basic burger you would get anywhere, from Big Boy to Biff's to any number of chains and restaurants. When I was a kid visiting NE for the summer, that was the norm here as well. I wonder when things switched. IMHO, it traces to increased patty size and prices as the "casual dining" places opened everywhere in the late 70's into the 80's. Eating a burger from a grill was more like steak cookery and thus more upscale.

                    B. Good is an excrescence.

                  2. re: yumyum

                    The place I first heard people talking about "east coast" and "west coast" burgers was the AHT blog. I always thought of it as "in-n-out" burgers vs. "pub" burgers

                    1. re: bobot

                      Oops - do they talk about that on AHT? If so, I apologize Adam! I didn't mean to usurp your classification system!

                  3. I think Flat Patties is a wonderful exemplar of its style, and I have to say that style is a more reliable style than the other style.

                    I should add that I don't eat at FP too often because I am concerned I will simply want more and more and get addicted. I don't ever feel that way with the bigger burgers.

                    1. One burger that I really love and cant stop eating is the Union Burger at Union Bar and Grill. The Andouille sausage mixed in with the ground beef makes it really good.

                      3 Replies
                      1. re: Matt H

                        Christopher's in Porter Square also does a burger with Andouille sausage mixed with the ground beef. It's very tasty.

                        1. re: afty698

                          Union Bar & Grille does that same trick with its burger, for $16, with great frites.


                          1. re: MC Slim JB

                            i like The Fireplace's lunch menu burger on a brioche-style bun and very good fries. at $8.99 the whole lunch is very good value.