HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >

Is Craft worth it?

josephnl Apr 20, 2009 12:20 PM

I've recently been hearing mixed reviews about Craft...both food and service, and also about it "not being worth it". We were planning to have dinner there after the theatre this coming Saturday, but are now having second thoughts. Has anyone been there recently? What did you have, and what did you think of the place? Is it worth it...or should we go to someplace for sure dependable like Sona or Melisse?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. b
    Bria Silbert RE: josephnl Apr 20, 2009 12:57 PM

    My husband, adult son and I were there three months ago for our thirtieth wedding anniversary. I found the prices well in line with the other top notch restaurants, the service very pleasant but unobtrusive and the food to be very good - not excellent, but certainly above address. I don't know if we ordered enough because I was not completely sated - always an issue when you order dishes to share for the table. I personally prefer ordering my own meal (OK with sharing dessert or app) but I would definitely go back for another meal there. I'd give it an 8 out of 10.

    1. d
      Danica21 RE: josephnl Apr 20, 2009 02:55 PM

      I went there with in-laws and my husband recently. The food is excellent and the service unbelievably friendly and relaxed. There is indoor and outdoor seating. My sister in law was pregnant and the waiter heard her say she was uncomfortable, and immediately had a pillow brought. We ordered six appetizers, four entrees and two desserts between six people and it was $50 apiece (no drinks, in-laws are teetotalers). I can't remember everything we got. The pig ears--odd choice, we did it to experiment and were glad--were great; the sea bass flavorful and succulent; the short ribs were winy and exceptionally well prepared, absolutely melting. Scallops were perfect. Anything with fish or meat was excellent. Salad was delicious, however not exceptional. They have a terrific variety of ice cream, the desserts we ordered (I remember the peanut butter cup tart) were not up to the standard of the food, but were yummy. You could get the desserts just as well at Alcove for maybe less (maybe the same) price. I highly recommend, especially if you are going to order a variety. Portions are small--you will eat well and not feel stuffed.

      1. r
        RicRios RE: josephnl Apr 20, 2009 03:12 PM

        As far as yours truly is concerned, Craft is the best joint in LA right now.

        2 Replies
        1. re: RicRios
          toddw8877 RE: RicRios Apr 20, 2009 05:12 PM

          Craft is worth every penny. I second RicRios opinion.

          1. re: toddw8877
            Jack Flash RE: toddw8877 Apr 22, 2009 04:52 PM


        2. n
          nosh RE: josephnl Apr 20, 2009 07:21 PM

          It may just be me, but in reading this board (and other reviews) I find more consistent satisfaction for Craft than either Sona or Melisse. If you are concerned about sticker shock but still want to check out the experience, I understand that Craft is now serving a more casual and much less expensive bar menu as well -- I don't know how restricted it is as to location or hours.

          1. j
            josephnl RE: josephnl Apr 26, 2009 09:55 AM

            To answer my own question...yes, definitely!!

            We went to Craft last night for dinner and our impression was one of overall excellence. We came away feeling that Craft may well be the best restaurant in L.A. right now, and if not, it is certainly in the top two or three.

            Although we are not hugh fans of the Zagat guides, but their rating system is useful. It gives 30 points for essentially unattainable perfection, and 0 points for the worst imaginable...in three categories, food, service, and ambiance. We would give Craft between 27 and 28 in all three categories. The food was excellent, and unlike another CH's comment that the portions are small, we found them more than adequate. We were served nothing that we didn't think was terrific from octopus, to salad, to fish, to duckling, to sorbets, to an incredible sundae. All was great. The service was warm, unfussy, not at all pretentious, and very polite, fun, knowledgeable and professional. The room is contemporary, but with much warmth. The furnishings are functional, comfortable and beautiul, the lighting close to perfect, and the tables properly spaced.

            Overall this is one terrific restaurant. It is not cheap, but we left feeling that we received pretty good value considering the high standard of everything we experienced.

            1. lotta_cox RE: josephnl Apr 26, 2009 10:06 AM

              I can only speak for the one in NYC, and while it was good not one of my favorites in NYC. but i find the service excellent and atmosphere really pleasant.

              1 Reply
              1. re: lotta_cox
                josephnl RE: lotta_cox Apr 26, 2009 10:33 AM

                Too bad! If you visit L.A., definitely try the Craft in Century City. You will be impressed!

              2. l
                Lizinla RE: josephnl Apr 26, 2009 04:09 PM

                Totally worth it!!!!! We loved it. Great Food!!!!!

                1. b
                  bruinike RE: josephnl Apr 26, 2009 05:07 PM

                  Where did you end up going? I am too late in my reply but I would have given my vote to CRAFT as well (although I've never been to Melisse).

                  1. s
                    SugarFrosted RE: josephnl Apr 26, 2009 11:56 PM

                    Yes! The foodie group that I organize was there in January and we were all blown away.
                    Party of 6 food fanatics. Everyone loved it. Our only complaint...two rib-eyes weren't enough
                    to share among us, but everything else was perfect. Don't miss the Lobster Fettucine, and make sure to order the Chocolate Souffle!

                    Show Hidden Posts