HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What have you made lately? Share your food adventure

Magnolia's frosting - too sweet! cavity inducing

asianbun Apr 16, 2009 07:58 AM

Took a bunch of out of towners there recently and remembered why i don't frequent Magnolia Bakery. The frosting is like pure sugar! barely any vanilla, just reconstituted powdered sugar with food coloring, and it's so sweet you feel cavities being formed. Why oh why is this style of frosting so popular? If you like it, please tell me why?

I prefer more buttery, vanilla-y, frosting like SSS, Crumbs, my local fave Pinisi, etc...

Even frosting from the grocery store cake mixes are better---thicker, richer-tasting, and more mouthfeel. I don't get it. i just don't get it.

  1. n
    nativeNYer Apr 16, 2009 09:24 AM

    I agree with you, asianbun. The perfect cupcake is the frosting from Buttercup Bakery on a Magnolia cupcake. The only Magnolia cupcakes I'll eat are the ones with chocolate frosting.

    1. k
      kathryn Apr 16, 2009 09:16 AM

      Asked and answered, your honor. :)


      Show Hidden Posts