What time do you make your reservation for pre-theater dinner?
I think you will really like the space Trecolori is now in. Much more attractive and comfortable than the old location. But what haven't changed are the delicious food and the friendly, efficient service. They do know how to get folks out in record time. However, I happen to like to relax when I dine out, and before a show, I want to leave time for my food to digest before sitting in a theater for a couple of hours. So, I would not make my reservation any later than 6 p.m.
Enjoy the show ("Avenue Q" is hilariously entertaining) and Buon Apetito!