Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
Apr 4, 2009 12:00 PM

Sedutto Ice Cream in Scarsdale on Garth Road

Sedutto's Ice Cream Shop is now open since March 27th.... It's on Garth Road where that other "healthy fro-yo/candy" store was. Right next to the Ballet store. I researched on Google, and it says its like an old school Staten Island ice cream company...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. if they have the Chocolate Peanut Butter hard frozen yogurt, it was always my favorite at the UES shop in Manhattan.

    1. They sure have the non-fat Chocolate Peanut Butter hard yogurt and over 45 flavors of super premium ice cream, soft ice cream, hard yogurt, soft yogurt, sorbet, and no sugar added ice cream. They also carry Frogurt Plain Yogurt -the one sold at Bloomingdales. They also make their own yogurt flavors like fluffer nutter, ohenry, etc just like the shop on the upper east side in Manhattan. Hours are currently from 11:30 am to 10 pm - closed on Sundays.

      1 Reply
      1. re: isee

        Thanks for the information! I gotta check them out!

      2. I finally got over to Sedutto yesterday. 1. It is the same guy that had the store on the UES (And hes so nice!) 2. They have a bajillion flavors that are really creative and delicious! Some are regular ice cream, some non fat, some sugar free, some frozen yogurt, plus they have the soft serve frozen yogurt in like 4 different flavors that change daily. 3. For people like me who are extremely indecisive when it comes to too many food options, they'll let you sample as any flavors as you like!

        I ended up with the (let's see if I get this right) sugar free fat free Cherry Vanilla, and Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip. So good! My bf got Moose Tracks and Cookies and Cream. Delish! Next time, I want to get the Milky Way, Banana Fudge, and whatever else I tried haha. Enjoy!

        1. On my second visit yesterday, I tried more stuff!! The plain fro-yo really is delish! I also got some Super Premium ice cream and its seriously fun and delicious! Check out my blog for pics...

          Summer is coming so put this place on your "To Go" list!