Ortolan 1st time - recs?
I've read the other board topics comparing ortolan to other similar upscale places, but can anyone give me specific recommendations - my wife and I are going for the first time for her birthday on Friday.
Should we just order a tasting menu or go a la carte? Help, any suggestions most appreciated!
From my one experience, which was terrible, I would suggest a la carte. We had the tasting menu, and along with the terrible service (despite the place being fairly empty) I was unhappy to being walking out with a bill over $500.
I have absolutely NO idea where the money went, as it certainly didn't seem to be the ingredients, the wines (pairing), nor the service, as I said.
Try the a la carte. Or, don't listen to me (I'm still just irritated) and go with the tasting menu. Many, many people love this place, so it's possible we were just there on an off night.
My husband has taken me for my birthday for the past three years, and we've had nothing but exemplary food, service & wine. I'm not sure what a213b ordered, or what day of the week he/she went, but I find it incredibly surprising. But that said, no restaurant & kitchen staff is perfect.
We always go on a weekend night (Fri or Sat) and order the tasting menu. Make sure to inform them you are celebrating your wife's birthday, and I bet you will get superior service. Chef Eme may even stop by your table; he always did for us.
Another plus is that the main room is incredibly gorgeous - a really romantic evening. Best of luck - I hope my rec doesn't fail you!!
We did the tasting menu with wine pairings on a Thursday night late last summer. We also had a couple of glasses of champagne to start with, before beginning the meal -- it was an anniversary dinner for us.
As I said the service on our one visit was sub-par and the food was mediocre (not terrible, but far from memorable).
For example, during the cheese course, as our server was preparing our plate, he kept commenting on how generous he was being in an effort to make up for some of the earlier lackluster dishes. Though certainly courteous and well-intentioned, we had a little private laugh to ourselves when we noted his "generosity"; 4 cheeses amounting to less than what I get when I ask for a sample at BH Cheese Store or Artisan. I wasn't expecting Cheesecake Factory portions here, but sheesh ... at that point we could not help but laugh and shake our heads. And that was the BEST of the service!
Regardless, I will say the main dining room is absolutely gorgeous -- a truly romantic spot. And from all of the raves I am trying to convince myself that dinner that evening was the exception, rather than the rule.
At some point I will go again, but I will definitely order from the a la carte menu.
Either of the two tasting menus are always a good way to go. If the tasting menus don't appeal, I think the langoustine are the best starter, though I also have had superb scallops there and also enjoy the escargot "parfait." For mains, he has a deft hand with lamb, duck and fish and I recently had delicious shortribs at brunch (also on the dinner menu). I would skip the pork entree--not the place's strong suit. Oh, usually you can get anything from the tasting menu a la carte if you ask nicely.
The meal can be slow if the place is busy--tiny kitchen--but the service I have received has always been attentive and special occasions have been handled very well. Enjoy!
I've been to Ortolan 4 times, each time we went with the tasting menu.
4 out of 4 times: Great food, competent service, good times.
Chef Eme is cordial. His wife Jeri (who is the hostess) is very nice also.
Tell them you're celebrating a special occasion. It should help to improve your experience (though I've only used that on them once before).
Our experience at Ortolan was excellent in terms of delicious food and thoughtful service.
We ordered a la carte and the highlights were the fois gras terrine appetizer and our entrees; the obscenely good squab and perfectly cooked duck. Note - the menu changes so these entrees might not be available right now.
Their cheese cart is quite impressive as well.