Coleslaw IMHO is creamy other wise it's just 'slaw'
Boiled dressing recipe -
Beat 2 yolks (or 1 egg) with 1/4 vinegar over low heat and add a combination of dry mustard, 1-2T sugar, salt, 2T flour, paprika that have been mixed in 1/2 water. Cook until thickened and finish with some butter.
one of the few foods that doesn't include extra fat or sugar from NC is the coleslaw served with pulled pork, NC style. Chop green cabbage fine and toss with lots of vinegar, for me, preferably infused with hot peppers and black pepper. Same sauce that goes on the pork. I'm from NC and of the Eastern style.
Vinegary vs. creamy: For me, it depends on the sauce. If the sauce is sweeter, I go with vinegary slaw. If the sauce is vinegary, I go with a creamy slaw. Generally I like slaw with some texture to it, but for going on top of pulled pork I chop it more finely--seems to go wih the texture of the pork a bit better. [No pretentions of authenticity here: This is just the way I like it.]
My husband (from Georgia) will only eat my cole slaw with his pulled pork -- or any other main dish. Too many slaws are too sweet, too creamy or have too many extraneous ingredients.
Here's what you do: Finely shred the cabbage. If I'm making a lot, I use the Cusinart 2mm slicing blade. Also finely chop some red onion. I slice it as finely as the cabbage and then chop it as well. Mix mayo and white vinegar in a 2 to 1 ratio -- e.g. 1 cup mayo to 1/2 cup vinegar. Add kosher salt, lots of freshly ground black pepper and about 1-2 teaspoons of sugar. Toss with the cabbage and taste for seasonings. Make sure you taste again after the slaw has chilled since it will likely need more salt. The tartness of the slaw is a fabulous contrast to the unctuousness of the pork. The BBQ sauce should have a tang as well.
Vinegary vs creamy
I think its a personal preference. I like vinegary.
The wife makes a slaw:
Shred (she uses a cheese grater) 1/2 head of cabbage
chop 2 green onions fine
chop 1/2 red onion fine
about 2 TBL or so of fresh parsely chopped fine
Mix in bowl
about 1/4C each white vinegar and veg oil (more or less on the final consistency)
2 TBL splenda (or sugar)
4 TBL vidalia onion salad dressing (we like Maple Grove Farms of Vermont)
S&P to taste
whisk dressing ingredients, stir into slaw, mix well and let meld in fridge an hour or overnite.
Not only good on pulled pork, but hot dogs, italian sausage sandwiches, sliced beef sandwiches, (also smash some fries on these last two sandwiches...oh boy) etc etc.
I soak my slaw-ready cabbage in ice water for about an hour and then drain well. Add vinegar, oil, salt, pepper, and a little sugar. Mix well. Add sweet pickle relish and some minced green onions. Sometimes add roasted sweet red peppers from the jar. Mix well and add mayo to desired consistency. The soaked cabbage won't "shrink" as much as regular cabbage, will stay crisp longer. Great for pork sandwiches.
Definitely less creamy, more vinegary. If you've every had the coleslaw at the Bear Pit in Mission Hills (KC type bbq), I think it's one of the best, and no mayo in it. But I've had pulled pork both ways, and it all depends on your particular taste.
Also, it depends on the type of bbq you're doing - sweet & sugary like KC or more vinegary & mustardy (no tomato), like No. Carolina. And then, of course, there's Memphis, which is no sauce, but with a peppery dry rub. Love them all!
I'm not the biggest Emeril fan, but this is a real winner. The only thing different that I do is salt the cabbage in a large colander about 2-3 hours before putting it together and drain the liquid that it secretes. Here's a link to Emeril's recipe--I've made it with my pulled pork on numerous occasions and people go crazy over it:
Well, I've been trying to get the page up, so I can post a link, but Foodtv site isn't responding. Just query Emeril pulled pork and cole slaw, and you should find it.
Den, gently asking: when was the last time you ate KFC coleslaw? I remember it being green, white with specks of carrot and a decent sweet but slightly vinegary taste...but when I tried it again about 6 months ago, YUCK--I threw it away after the first bite after noticing how different it even looked...it was all white and pasty, total sugar glop...ack! They'd obviously changed the recipe big time...at least here in SW FL, though I'd have to think this would be a commodity that fast food places keep pretty uniform.
personal favourite is a nice half and half mix, you get the vinegary bite with a little mayo in there. It really will come down to what your preference is,
equal parts mayo and vinegar
season to taste (salt, pepper, garlic granules etc).
If you want a recipe for coleslaw I use just a simple
4 parts cabbage
1 part purple cabbage
carrots for a bit of flavour and colour.