Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
Mar 11, 2009 01:26 PM

Best Red Velvet Cake in Hudson Valley Area?

I know Lulu's has a red velvet cake but I've never tried it. People rave about Lulu's but haven't heard someone who's ever tried their red velvet. If I order from Lulu's and don't customize, do I need to order ahead to reserve one? There's also Carousel Cakes that Oprah named her favorite red velvet cake in 2005 or 2006. But I'm not a big big fan. It's only ok. I want this cake to be spectacular!

What are some other bakeries that make good red velvet cake in the Westchester/Rockland area? It's my sister's favorite kind of cake and I'm planning to order one for her baby shower, not sure if I want to customize it or not.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. It's not a bakery, but X20 Xaviar's on the Hudson had the best Red Velvet Cake I've ever tasted, and I'm not even a huge fan of Red Velvet Cake. Maybe it's worth giving them a call and seeing if they'd do a whole cake for you.

    4 Replies
    1. re: SharonNY

      I totally agree!! I still think of that tall, beautiful cake with mascarpone frosting. I have a photo on my cell phone, will try to post it.

      1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream

        Why not bake it yourself? There are tons of recipes online and I plan on using my old, old, old one for my son's groom's cake!

        1. re: shopgirl

          I would make it myself but I want people to actually like it. (I'm not a good cook/baker AT ALL. My sister's actualy the one who's the cook in the family but I can't exactly ask her to make her own cake. haha

          I'll look into x20 xavier's

          1. re: sash007

            If you go to Lulu's don't be fooled by their take on a red velvet cake -- it automatically comes with vanilla kind of frosting but NOT cream cheese - -you have to tell them you want cream cheese frosting or you will be disappointed.

            My brother-in-law had one for his 50th birthday party and they put some kind of crunchy candy praline pecans in the cream cheeese in it it was out of this world.

    2. The only red velvet cake I've had in Westchester was from Riviera for my daughter's birthday - dry and tasteless. However, there was an article in the NYT last year about a woman in Tarrytown who will bake cakes to order, and the red velvet cake looked so good that I jotted down the website: . I'd suggest checking that one out!

      4 Replies
      1. re: Retrokitch

        I've not had their red velvet cake, but had an outstanding carrot cake from Lloyds in Riverdale/Bronx last weekend. Worth the little drive. Had great cream cheese frosting, and they did have red velvet cake on the menu.

          1. re: shoekittykat

            In Riverdale, near Manhattan College. I don't know the address off hand and have only been there once.


            Worth the trip, in my opinion. Had awesome carrot cake from there, assuming red velvet will follow suit.

            1. re: shoekittykat

              Here's Lloyd's address:

              6087 Broadway
              Riverdale, NY 10471

              It's right off the Saw Mill/Hen Hud Pkwy. Been a huge fan of their carrot cakes for years. I still haven't tried their red velvet, but plan to. Definitely try a slice - all of their goodies are very reasonably priced too.

        1. The original comment has been removed
          1. also would give a conditional vote for LLoyd's, just had their carrot cake for the first time and would definitely recommend it, did not try the red velvet though and very reasonable price too

            1. We thought red velvet was very good. Lola's teahouse in Pelham used to sell it by the slice, I don't know if they still do. I don't think Lloyd's red velvet is very good at all its very dry,not nearly as good as their carrot cake. I agree that X20 red velvet is great.