Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >
Mar 7, 2009 06:55 PM

Schnitzel - Very Disappointing - Bread & Butter, Mt. Pleasant & Millwood

I tried this place on March 6 after reading all the positive reports about how great the food was here. They claim to have Toronto's best schnitzel. I was very disappointed.

I was there around 3 or 4 pm, with 4 other customers present. The young woman server on duty was bored, shuffled around and provided mediocre service. The schnitzel would rank as barely average: it is made who knows how long in advance and is nuked when you order it. it is impossible for schnitzel to be crispy and good unless it is freshly made. Ditto with the mashed potatoes and the other sides, made far in advance and nuked.

The server could not even manage to get the food hot enough using the microwave. I had to take my goulash soup back, and ask her to nuke it for another 60 seconds. When I told her it was barely lukewarm and it needed to be reheated, she asked "Are you sure?" I've had far better goulash soup at Country Style on Bloor West. Some pieces of the beef were tough and inedible, and there were very few of them.

The mashed potatoes were barely lukewarm for both myself and another customer. When the other customer (a regular, apparently) told her the mashed potatoes were cold, the server again said. "Are you sure?" The customer replied pleasantly "In this country, honey, the customer is always right." But I ate the lukewarm potatoes anyway because I feared longer in the microwave would make the schnitzel tough and inedible.

I tried the apple strudel for dessert when I checked that it was house-made, and because commentators said their sweets were great. It was horrible because the cook couldn't be bothered to peel the apples and must have chopped them skin and all in the food processor. The filling was filled with nasty tough small pieces of skin. The server was going to give the strudel to me cold from the refrigerated case. When I asked her to heat it, the microwave made the phyllo pastry soggy and hard to cut with a fork.

I doubt very much I will go back, neither the food nor the service was good, and I was very puzzled by the fact this place is supposed to be a neighbourhood icon, patronized by many for 20 or 30 years. Maybe the owners and staff are all getting tired and bored.

Bread & Butter
507 Mt Pleasant Rd, Toronto, ON M4S, CA

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
    1. re: redearth

      What do you recommend here? I just checked out the menu and it doesnt describe the dishes, so what do the mains come with or do you buy sides a la carte?

      1. re: hungryabbey

        All the mains I've tried have come with potatoes and veg. Try the "Barbecue Pork Hox"! It's enough for two people! Zer gut!

        1. re: redearth

          thanks for your suggestion! What is pork hox exactly?

          1. re: hungryabbey

            Also known as Schweinhaxe, it is a pork hock simmered for a couple of hours then roasted to crisp up the skin. Some versions of the dish are smoked. I can't honestly recall whether the Musket's version is smoked or not (it's been a while since I've been).

    2. Agree 100%. We went a couple of months back after reading all the positive posts here. I could not believe that "Toronto's Best Schnitzel" was made way in advance and then put in the microwave. Terrible. Maybe this place was good back in the day, and people like it because they remember the good old days.

      I have had better schnitzel sandwiches at Pumpernickel's. At least it is hot.

      We will never go back, and whenever we drive by this place, we get mad that we went there, and were so disappointed.

      Good post.

      1. That's too bad, it used to be a decent place for a quick lunch, although "Toronto's best schnitzel" was always a stretch.

        Bread & Butter
        507 Mt Pleasant Rd, Toronto, ON M4S, CA

        1. just actually found this site by mistake and dont really consider myself a food snob but I've had many schnitzel from this place and their AWESOME!

          I mean lets get serious, where can you go and get a massive meal like this one which is most definitely made with real meat (chicken schnitzel is my favourite) for under $10 with a drink? Obviously you must have attended a French culinary institute but for the ordinary folk like myself, the schnitzel cant be beat!

          As for the dessert, try the chocolat rasberry cake thing they got going.

          Hope I didnt ruffle your feathers but I've been going here for years and honestly and truthfully love the food (enough to actually bother setting up an account and typing here).

          N E ways, good eatin'